The 8 Best Cookie Cutters of 2026

A cookie cutter is the simplest thing in the kitchen drawer, which is exactly why it's so easy to buy badly. The cheap stamped ones bend the first time you lean on cold dough, water sneaks into the seam and rusts it orange by February, and the size on the ring is often a quarter inch off from what it claims, which quietly changes how many cookies a batch makes. None of that shows up in a photo of a snowman.

I bake constantly — weeknight biscuits, a December that smells like molasses — and 16 sets have now been through our kitchen, from plain nested rounds to full holiday collections. The ones worth keeping felt the same in the hand: real stainless steel, a rolled top edge that doesn't bite, a wall firm enough not to flex mid-cut.

One thing first-time buyers get wrong: more shapes isn't better. A dozen graduated rounds earn their drawer space all year, while a dozen novelty shapes get used once.

Our Top Picks

The Best Cookie Cutters

1

Bukuwa 12-Piece Round Cookie Cutter Set Best Overall

Bukuwa twelve-piece stainless steel round cookie cutter set nested in a metal storage tin

Everyday cookie baking

Bake Score 98/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Cutters
12
Material
18/8 stainless steel
Size Range
1 to 4.4 inches
View on Amazon

Twelve round cutters, from 1 inch across to 4.4 inches, nested in a tin small enough to live in a drawer: that is the pitch, and it is why this set is the one we recommend first. Rounds are the workhorses of cookie baking — cookies, biscuits, donut holes, a neat round of dough for a hand pie — and this set covers the whole range without making you buy four separate sets.

We appreciated the finishing the moment we pressed one into chilled dough. The top edges are rolled and the weld seams are smooth, so bearing down with the heel of your hand does not leave a line across your palm, and the 18/8 stainless goes in the dishwasher. That last part matters more than it sounds: cutters are sticky, fiddly things, and a set you can toss in the rack gets used far more often than one you have to scrub.

Where the set earns its place every week is the spread. The 4.4-inch ring stamps a round for a breakfast sandwich or an English muffin, the middle sizes handle standard cookies, and the 1- and 1 1/2-inch rings turn trimmings into donut holes instead of a re-rolled, toughened sheet of dough.

Because they nest, all twelve take up the footprint of the largest one, and the tin is the quiet win — small rings vanish into a drawer and come back bent. The steel is rated to 500°F, too, so a ring can go into the oven around a round of dough when you want a straight edge on a small deep-dish cookie.

Worth Noting

  • Walls flex on very firm, cold dough
Our Verdict

Our pick for most bakers: twelve dishwasher-safe rounds from 1 to 4.4 inches give you every size you will actually use, and the tin keeps them together.

Check Latest Price
2

HULISEN Biscuit Cutter Set Best with Handles

HULISEN three-piece stainless steel biscuit cutter set with arched handles and etched sizes

Biscuits and scones

Bake Score 97/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Cutters
3
Sizes
1 3/4, 2 3/4, 3 1/4 inches
Handles
Arched
View on Amazon

A cutter with a handle is a different tool in the hand. Instead of pinching a thin rim between your fingers, you press the HULISEN's arched handle with a flat palm and push straight down, so the pressure lands evenly and the ring does not rock. That, plus the sizes etched into the steel in both inches and centimeters, is why this is the set we pick up when we are cutting biscuits rather than cookies.

Three cutters — 1 3/4, 2 3/4, and 3 1/4 inches — is a deliberate limit, and for biscuits it is the right one. The big ring cuts a generous biscuit or a burger bun, the middle size handles scones and English muffins, and the smallest is for small rounds and small appetites. If you bake one batch on Sunday morning, three is plenty.

The steel is heavy enough that the rings hold their shape, and the cut edges are thin enough to leave a clean line rather than a squashed one. They travel on a metal ring, though the clasp takes a thumbnail and some patience to open — we hang ours inside a cabinet door rather than wrestling with it each time.

Dishwasher safe, and the packaging is sturdy enough that a set leaves the house looking like a gift rather than a hardware order.

Worth Noting

  • Only three sizes
Our Verdict

For biscuits, scones, and English muffins, the handles and etched sizes make this the most comfortable cutter here, as long as three sizes are all you need.

Check Latest Price
3

MINO ANT Stainless Steel Cookie Cutter Set Best Shape Variety

MINO ANT six-piece stainless steel shaped cookie cutters including heart star unicorn and dinosaur

Party shapes

Bake Score 96/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Cutters
6
Material
Stainless steel
Shapes
Mickey Mouse, unicorn, dinosaur, heart, star
View on Amazon

Rounds do the everyday work; these do the birthday. The MINO ANT set is six shaped cutters — Mickey Mouse, unicorn, dinosaur, heart, and star among them — stamped from stainless steel with rolled top edges and safe in the dishwasher.

We rate a shaped set on what it saves you: one box that covers a party, a Valentine's tray, and a batch of dinosaur cookies for a school fair, rather than six single cutters bought one at a time. The outlines are simple, which is the right call. A cutter with fussy internal detail makes cookies that are hard to ice and harder to lift out of the ring.

Two things to know. Each shape comes in one size, so a big heart and a small heart from the same set is not happening, and there are no plain rounds here — this is a supplement to a set like the Bukuwa, not a replacement. The shapes are cookie-sized rather than platter-sized, which suits sandwich bread, lunchboxes, and small hands.

Worth Noting

  • One size per shape
  • No plain rounds included
Our Verdict

Buy it for the shapes: six clean, dishwasher-safe outlines that cover birthdays and holidays, in one size each.

Check Latest Price
4

Ann Clark Christmas Cookie Cutter Set Best Holiday Set

Ann Clark eleven-piece Christmas cookie cutter set in American steel with holiday shapes

Christmas projects

Bake Score 95/100
Care
Hand wash only
Cutters
11
Material
Food-safe American steel
Shape Sizes
3 to 4 inches
View on Amazon

Eleven Christmas shapes in one box — a snowflake, a star, a tree, a gingerbread man, an angel, a reindeer, a candy cane, and more — most of them three and a half to four inches across. That is a different proposition from a graduated set of rounds: these are cutters for a project, an afternoon of rolling and icing that fills tins for the neighbors.

The size is the point. A four-inch gingerbread man leaves room for a piped face and buttons, while a small cutter of the same shape gives you a gingerbread blob. The walls are deep and the edges sharp, so the shapes release cleanly when you lift straight up, and the steel is food-safe American steel made in Vermont.

It is the priciest set here by a wide margin, and what you are paying for is the shapes, the depth, and the domestic steel. Whether that adds up depends entirely on how much of your December happens at the counter.

Our view: if holiday cookies are a tradition in your house, these are the shapes guests recognize and the depth is what makes them easy to decorate. If you bake all year and want Christmas once, the inexpensive festive set further down this list will do the job and leave more in the butter budget.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only; steel rusts if left wet
Our Verdict

The holiday set we recommend: eleven deep, generous shapes that leave room for icing, made in the US from food-safe steel.

Check Latest Price
5

KSPOWWIN 5-Piece Biscuit Cutter Set Best Budget

KSPOWWIN five-piece stainless steel round biscuit cutter set with nested graduated rings

Budget baking

Bake Score 94/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Cutters
5
Material
Stainless steel
Shape
Round
View on Amazon

Five nested rounds, roughly 1 3/4 inches to 3 1/3 inches across, with rolled top edges and a dishwasher-safe finish: the KSPOWWIN set covers the sizes most cookies actually need, and it does it for very little money.

The polished steel releases dough with a small shake instead of a fight, and the rolled rims are kind to your palm when you are pressing through a cold sheet. Because the five nest inside each other, the whole set takes up the footprint of the largest ring, which matters in a drawer that already holds too much.

Our take: five is a sensible number. You get a small ring for cookie bites and appetizer rounds, a middle pair for standard cookies, and one at the top for biscuits and buns, without the sprawl of a twelve-piece set where half the sizes never get touched. For someone who bakes a few times a month and does not want to think about it, that is a better trade than a bigger box.

Worth Noting

  • Thin walls can bend out of round
Our Verdict

A sensible five-size set for bakers who want the useful rounds without the sprawl, at a price that makes it an easy second set.

Check Latest Price
6

Husfunov Biscuit Cutter Set

Husfunov five-piece stainless steel round cookie cutter set with arched handles and gift box

Handled value set

Bake Score 93/100
Care
Hand wash only
Cutters
5
Sizes
1 3/4, 2, 2 1/4, 2 3/4, 3 1/4 inches
Height
1 3/4 inches
View on Amazon

If the HULISEN set is the finished version of a handled cutter, the Husfunov is the value version: the same arched handle soldered to a round steel ring, but five sizes instead of three, and hand-wash-only steel instead of a dishwasher-safe one.

The cutters run 1 3/4, 2, 2 1/4, 2 3/4, and 3 1/4 inches across, with walls 1 3/4 inches tall. That height is the underrated number. Tall, straight walls cut through a thick biscuit dough in one push, and they give a sourdough English muffin a straight side instead of a tapered one.

The arched handle and the soldered joints are the other reason these feel better than the price suggests. On stiff, chilled dough the arch presses into your palm a little — a flat hand and a firm push solve that — but for soft cookie dough it is comfortable, and it keeps your fingers off the rim.

Where we land: this is the set for someone who bakes biscuits and cookies often, does not mind washing up by hand, and would rather have five sizes than three. If the dishwasher is non-negotiable, the HULISEN costs a little more and takes the rack.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only
Our Verdict

Five handled sizes for less than the three-piece sets here, with tall walls that cut biscuits cleanly, as long as you will wash them by hand.

Check Latest Price
7

SOSOHOME Christmas Cookie Cutter Set Best for Small Holiday Treats

SOSOHOME five-piece stainless steel Christmas cookie cutters with snowman tree and candy cane

Small holiday treats

Bake Score 92/100
Care
Hand wash only
Cutters
5
Material
Stainless steel
Shapes
Snowman, Christmas tree, gingerbread man, candy cane, snowflake
View on Amazon

Small is the first thing to know about the SOSOHOME set. A snowman that fits on a sandwich, a candy cane that tops a mug of cocoa, a gingerbread man small enough for a lunchbox — these are decorating cutters more than cookie-tray cutters, and that is fine as long as you know it going in.

We rate them for exactly that job: an afternoon with kids, cookies that bake in a few minutes and take a squirt of icing, shapes that do not demand precision. Five classics — snowman, tree, gingerbread man, candy cane, and snowflake — in stainless steel with rolled top edges, and light enough for a child to press down without help.

If you want big decorated cookies for a cookie swap, this is not the set; the Ann Clark shapes are roughly twice the size. But for small treats, class parties, and a first baking session with a kid at the counter, it is a lot of fun for very little money.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only
Our Verdict

A cheap, cheerful set for small holiday cookies and baking with kids: buy it for decoration-sized shapes, not showpiece cookies.

Check Latest Price
8

ZDHSOY 3-Piece Cookie Cutter Set Best for Small Kitchens

ZDHSOY three-piece stainless steel round cookie cutter set with smooth rolled edges

Small kitchens

Bake Score 91/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Cutters
3
Height
1.4 inches
Diameters
3.2, 2.8, 2.4 inches
View on Amazon

Three rings and less than three ounces of steel: the ZDHSOY set takes up less drawer space than a mug, which is the whole argument if your kitchen is small or you bake biscuits a few times a month rather than every week.

The diameters are 3.2, 2.8, and 2.4 inches, all 1.4 inches tall, in 304 stainless with rolled top edges and a dishwasher-safe finish. The walls are tall enough to cut a proper biscuit in one push rather than sawing at the dough, and the three sizes cover a large biscuit, a standard one, and small cookies.

Our take: three sizes is the right number for biscuit cutters, and this set is compact enough to keep in a drawer rather than a box in the basement. These are not the stoutest rings here — the joins are the part to watch, and hand washing keeps them tight — but they cut cleanly and cost the least of anything on this list.

Our Verdict

The compact choice for biscuit bakers: three tall rounds that cut cleanly, take up no space, and cost the least here.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested the Best Cookie Cutters

We began with about 60 sets — the baking-aisle standards, the online bestsellers, the holiday boxes — and cut that down to 16 by asking whether the maker named the steel alloy, whether the pieces nested for storage, and whether the size range did more than one job. Anything with an unfinished seam or a price that worked out to pennies per cutter was out. Those 16 ran the full four months, beginning with a December of gingerbread and continuing through a spring of weekend biscuits.

Most of the work happened where cutters actually live: on a floured counter at 8 a.m. on a Sunday, and at 10 p.m. on a weeknight when the dough was already rolled. We cut cold butter dough straight from the fridge, sticky gingerbread, pie crust, and dumpling wrappers, noting whether the edge sliced clean or dragged and whether dough packed into the corners of the shape instead of releasing. One set also went to a four-year-old for an afternoon of Play-Doh, which is the fastest durability test we know.

Every set was washed by hand and in the dishwasher on alternating cycles, and half were left damp in the drying rack overnight on purpose; every couple of weeks we looked inside the seams and under the rim for orange bloom. We measured each cutter's opening against its listed size — a few were off by a quarter inch — and checked whether the sizes printed on the packaging held up to a ruler. To judge grip, I cut forty rounds in a row with each set and noted which handles left a red ridge in my palm. At the end we tallied cost per cutter that actually worked, which is where the biggest holiday boxes quietly lost.

How to Choose Cookie Cutters

Buy the sizes, not the piece count

A twelve-piece set sounds like more value than a three-piece one until you notice that half the rings differ by a quarter inch. What matters is the range: a set running from about an inch to four inches covers cookie bites, standard cookies, biscuits, and a round for a breakfast sandwich. The Bukuwa set is built on that logic, and it is why we make it the default.

If you mostly bake biscuits and scones, three well-chosen rounds are genuinely enough, and a compact set keeps a small drawer usable. Look for even jumps between sizes so you can scale a cookie up or down without hunting for a missing in-between.

Wall height and stiffness decide the cut

A cutter with tall, straight walls cuts through thick or chilled dough in one push; a shallow one presses a line the dough rises over in the oven. Height is usually listed, so compare it before you buy — 1.4 to 1 3/4 inches is a working depth for biscuits, while older-fashioned shapes often sit around an inch.

Stiffness you judge by the rim and the weight in your hand. Rolled top edges and solid solder hold their round when you lean on them; thin rings flex, and once a ring is oval it cuts oval cookies forever.

Rounds or shapes?

Plain rounds do the everyday work — cookies, biscuits, crackers, donut holes, ravioli — and round biscuit cutters are the set to buy first. Shaped cutters are for occasions, and most sets give you one size per shape, so you cannot scale a heart up for a cake or down for a cookie bite.

Buy shapes for the trays you actually make: winter holidays, birthdays, a school party. A themed set that stays in the cupboard is worse value than a plain set you reach for weekly.

Handles, rings, and where the set lives

A handle lets you press with a flat palm instead of pinching a thin rim, which matters on stiff dough and for children helping at the counter. The trade is storage: handled cutters do not nest as tightly, though most arrive on a stacking ring that keeps the set together.

Plain rings nest into the footprint of the largest one, and a tin stops the small sizes disappearing into a drawer. If space is tight, nesting plus a container beats a bigger set every time.

Care: what can go in the dishwasher

Stainless sets marked dishwasher safe can go in the rack, and that convenience is why they get used on a Tuesday night. American-steel cutters of the kind Ann Clark makes are hand wash only and will rust if left wet, so dry them the moment they come out of the sink.

Even on dishwasher-safe sets, check the joins on inexpensive rings; a hot cycle can work solder loose over a season, and hand washing keeps a cheap set tight.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

The Bukuwa 12-piece set is the one we point most bakers to: twelve dishwasher-safe rounds from 1 to 4.4 inches cover cookies, biscuits, and donut holes, and the tin means you will still have all twelve next year. If biscuits are your thing, the HULISEN's handles and etched sizes are worth the narrower range.

If you bake one big holiday batch a year, the Ann Clark Christmas set is the one deep enough to leave room for icing. Start with rounds and add shapes when an occasion asks for them.