Wilton Platinum Non-Stick Square Pan Best Overall
- Care
- Dishwasher safe
- Size
- 9 x 9 in
- Coating
- Silicone-infused nonstick
- Handles
- Extended
A square pan has one structural job: stay flat when the oven hits it. Thin steel buckles, and a buckled pan sets its batter lopsided, which is why warp resistance is the first thing we check. The Wilton Platinum is the most convincing pan here on that count, with a steel body, a solid rim, and the anti-warping build Wilton is explicit about. Nine inches of level baking surface is what you are buying.
The coating is the second reason it tops this list. Wilton's DuraLast is a silicone-infused double layer that resists scratching far better than the spray-on coatings on cheaper pans, and brownies release from it with a light swipe of butter and a thin spatula. It is made without PFAS, which matters if you are replacing a pan whose surface has gone patchy. Extended handles give you room for a mitt, and the whole pan goes in the dishwasher.
At 1.6 pounds it is one of the heavier 9-inch pans in this group, and that heft is what you feel when a full pan of batter slides onto the rack without a wobble. The extra money over the Farberware goes into the coating and the rim, and those are the two parts that decide how many years you get.
What We Like
- Stays flat in a hot oven
- Silicone-infused coating resists scratching
- Goes in the dishwasher with extended handles
Worth Noting
- Coating scratches if you cut in the pan
We recommend it first: a 9-inch pan that stays flat, releases brownies cleanly, and can go in the dishwasher.
Check Latest Price