Cuisinart 16-Inch Roasting Pan with Rack Best Overall
- Oven Safe
- 500 °F
- Pan Dimensions
- 20.7"L x 12"W x 4.9"H
- Construction
- Single-ply stainless steel
- Rack Included
- Stainless steel
A 24-pound turkey is the number we kept coming back to. This Cuisinart measures 20.7 by 12 inches, and a bird that size sits down inside it with the rack in place and the handles still clear for a mitt. Plenty of roasters are rated for a big bird; the difference here is that it undercuts the clad pans in this group and still arrives with a rack, a 500 °F rating, and a lifetime warranty.
The uncoated surface is the quieter advantage. There is no finish to bubble, peel, or flake into the gravy, which is where pans in this category actually fail, and burnt-on glaze lifts after a ten-minute soak. It is dishwasher safe, and the tapered rim pours a quart of drippings without sending a runnel down the outside of the pan.
Single-ply steel is the trade. Heat reaches the middle of the pan faster than the corners, so give a full sheet of root vegetables a turn halfway through, and do not plan on making the gravy in it: pour the drippings into a skillet and deglaze there. What that buys you is a pan light enough to pull out of the oven one-handed while the other hand steadies the bird.
What We Like
- Holds a 24-pound bird with the rack in
- Uncoated steel cannot flake into food
- Dishwasher safe and oven safe to 500 °F
Worth Noting
- Handles stick out well past the rim
We recommend the Cuisinart to anyone who wants one pan that fits the biggest bird their oven will take, shrugs off the dishwasher, and leaves the clad money on the table.
Check Latest Price