Rubbermaid Brilliance Pantry Set Best Overall
- Footprint
- 11.5 x 8.25 x 11.31 in
- Sizes Included
- 16, 12 and 7.8 cups
- Total Capacity
- 35.8 cups
- Material
- BPA-free Tritan plastic
The container that matters in this set is the middle one. A five-pound bag of granulated sugar is a little over eleven cups, and that container holds twelve, so the bag goes in whole with just enough headroom to get a measuring cup under the rim. The 16-cup container takes the flour, the 7.8-cup one handles powdered sugar or a box of brown sugar, and one purchase covers the baking shelf. That is why it leads this list.
The seal is the second reason. Four latches pull the lid down onto a gasket and close with an audible click, and of everything we handled, this is the seal we trust most — the airtight feedback on this set is stronger than on any other pick here. Sugar does not spoil, but it pulls moisture out of the air and hardens, and it takes on the smell of whatever sits beside it. A lid that actually seals is the product.
Tritan earns its keep too. It is clear from every angle, so you can see how low the sugar has gotten without lifting anything; it goes in the dishwasher; and it resists staining and holding odors, which matters once a container has spent a winter full of cinnamon sugar. It also shrugs off drops in a way the glass picks here cannot.
Set against the four-piece sets below, the price is steeper per set and gentler per container. The thing we cannot argue away is the footprint: three containers this size claim about a foot of cabinet shelf once stacked as designed. Measure that shelf before you order, because everything else about this set is the easy part.
What We Like
- Four-latch lid with a real gasket
- 12-cup container fits a 5-lb bag of sugar
- Shatter-resistant Tritan, dishwasher safe
Worth Noting
- Costs more than the four-piece sets
- Three containers claim about a foot of shelf
The set we recommend first: three truly airtight sizes, the middle one sized for a five-pound bag of sugar, in plastic that shrugs off drops and the dishwasher.
Check Latest Price