Chicago Metallic Commercial II French Bread Pan Best Overall
- Loaves
- 2
- Pan Size
- 16.38 x 8 x 2.5 in
- Oven-safe To
- 450°F
- Care
- Dishwasher safe
The case for a perforated pan is simple: hot air has to reach the underside of the loaf. This one does it better than anything else in the group, because the holes run the full length of both wells and the heavy-gauge metal beneath them holds its heat instead of dumping it. We baked a pair of loaves in it and got a shell that crackled as it cooled, browned underneath where a solid pan leaves a pale stripe.
What keeps us coming back is how little the release takes. The dual-layer nonstick let both loaves slide out whole, and the pan wiped clean instead of soaking. That is the difference between a pan you reach for on a Sunday and one that lives in the drawer.
The wells are broader than a classic baguette trough, so loaves come out closer to a fat French loaf than a pencil-thin baton. For sandwiches, garlic bread, and anything you slice thick, that is a plus; if you are chasing a crackly, slim baguette with a sharp edge, the USA Pan is the better tool. It also claims a full rack at 16 inches across, so a second pan waits its turn.
A lifetime warranty, a dishwasher-safe rating, and a 450°F ceiling round it out. We hand-washed ours anyway, mostly out of habit, but it is nice not to have to.
What We Like
- Perforations brown the crust all around
- Dual-layer nonstick releases loaves whole
- Lifetime warranty and dishwasher safe
Worth Noting
- Bakes only two loaves per batch
We recommend it as the pan to buy first: broad wells, a crackling crust, and a coating that lets loaves out whole.
Check Latest Price