Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Loaf Pan Best Overall
- Material
- Stoneware
- Care
- Dishwasher safe
- Dimensions
- 9" x 5" x 3"
- Capacity
- 1.5 quarts
Stoneware heats slowly and then holds what it has, and that is the difference you taste in a loaf: the crust sets evenly from end to end instead of darkening at the corners while the middle catches up. The interior measures 9 by 5 by 3 inches and holds 1.5 quarts — the size most American loaf recipes assume — so banana bread, a sandwich loaf, and a pound cake all bake without scaling.
It is the only glazed stoneware pan in this group; everything else is metal under a ceramic coating, and the coating is the part that eventually fails. Here the enameled surface is nonporous, so it doesn't hold the flavor of last week's meatloaf, it resists staining and scratching, and it goes in the dishwasher. Le Creuset backs it with a limited lifetime warranty, and the pan is rated from -9°F to 500°F, which means freezer to oven works.
The trade-off is weight. Two pounds empty, and awkward one-handed once it's hot, so lifting it out takes both mitts and a steady grip. We minded that less than we expected, because the payoff is heat retention: bread stays warm in the pan through a second cup of coffee, and the dish goes straight to the table. It's also the most expensive pan here by a wide margin. Bake weekly and we think it earns that; bake a loaf a month and one of the coated pans will do the same job for less.
What We Like
- Browns loaves evenly end to end
- Standard 9-by-5 size suits most recipes
- Dishwasher safe with a lifetime warranty
Worth Noting
- Heavy and awkward to lift when hot
- Highest price in this group
Our pick for most bakers: real stoneware in the standard 9-by-5 size, with even browning, dishwasher cleanup, and no coating to peel.
Check Latest Price