USA Pan 1145LF Best Overall
- Size
- 9 x 5 x 2.75 inches
- Oven Safe
- 450 °F
- Care
- Hand wash
- Coating
- Silicone, PTFE- and PFOA-free
Run a finger along the inside of this pan and the first thing you notice is the ridges. That corrugated surface isn't styling: it holds the batter a hair off the metal so hot air moves around the loaf, and it shrinks the contact patch between bread and pan, which is why a loaf comes free with a hand underneath instead of a knife around the edge.
It's the pan we reach for first in this group, and the steel is the reason. Aluminized and heavy gauge, with a rim that doesn't flex when you lift a full pan one-handed, it browned a pumpkin loaf evenly from corner to corner and gave the sides the same color as the top — no dark band where the wall meets the base, which is exactly what a thin pan gives you.
The finish is Americoat, a silicone coating made without PTFE, PFOA, or BPA, and it wants a light touch rather than a heavy coat of spray: a smear of butter and a dust of flour is plenty. This is a bright, light-colored pan, so loaves brown more gently than they do in a dark one and often want a few extra minutes. Start checking when the recipe says and give it a little more time.
What the price buys is the part you don't see in the first loaf — a limited lifetime warranty, U.S. manufacturing from globally sourced steel, and a finish that still looked new after weeks of use. The 1.25-pound size is a true 9 x 5 x 2.75, deep enough for a meatloaf as well as a sandwich loaf, and the corners are the only spot that needs a small brush.
What We Like
- Browns evenly from corner to corner
- Loaves release with light greasing only
- Coating free of PTFE, PFOA, and BPA
- Limited lifetime warranty and U.S. manufacturing
Worth Noting
- Hand wash only
We think most bakers should buy this one: it browns evenly, releases without coaxing, and its coating is the most durable in this group.
Check Latest Price