GoodCook BestBake Cookie Sheet Best Overall
- Material
- Carbon steel
- Size
- 11 x 17 in
- Surface
- Textured diamond nonstick
- Side Walls
- 4- to 5-degree bakery angle
Run a hand across the bottom of this sheet and you feel the idea behind it: a raised diamond pattern pressed into the steel. Those ridges hold a cookie or a chicken thigh a hair off the surface, so hot air moves underneath instead of sitting in a pocket of steam. By the second tray we noticed the difference, with bottoms coming out an even gold across the whole sheet instead of dark in the middle and pale at the corners.
The side walls are the detail we did not expect to care about. GoodCook rolls them at a four- to five-degree angle, closer to a commercial bakery pan than to the flared cookie sheets most of us grew up with, so bar cookies and sheet cakes come out with square corners and an even thickness. That, plus the price, is why this is the sheet we reach for first.
Eleven by seventeen is the size we recommend before anything larger. It fits a standard home oven with room to spare and handles a dozen cookies, a tray of vegetables, or a weeknight dinner for four. It is not a true half sheet, so a recipe written for an 18-by-13 pan will spread a little thinner here and bake a touch faster.
The coating is the part to protect. It is scratch-resistant rather than scratch-proof, so keep metal spatulas and pizza wheels off it and wash it by hand even when you do not feel like it. Otherwise this is about as low-maintenance as a baking sheet gets.
What We Like
- Textured surface releases cookies without parchment
- Rolled side walls give bar cookies clean corners
- Stays flat through repeated oven use
- Costs less than any other pick here
Worth Noting
- Smaller than a true half sheet
We tell anyone buying a single carbon steel sheet to start here: it stayed flat, released cleanly, and costs less than every set on this page.
Check Latest Price