The 8 Best Nonstick Pizza Pans of 2026

Friday night pizza is a great idea right up until you go to lift the first slice and the crust stays welded to the pan. I've mangled more than one pie that way, and the culprit is rarely the dough — it's a coating that has given up or a surface that never got hot enough underneath. A good nonstick pizza pan releases cleanly, browns the bottom before the toppings dry out, and stays slick through bake after bake.

We've made pizza on 12 of them — 12-inch rounds, wide 16-inch pans, and a couple of deep dish models — and the differences show up fast. Nonstick is a wear item here, so the question isn't whether a pan is slick on day one but whether it's still slick, and still easy to wipe clean, after months of 500-degree Fridays. One thing worth knowing: a 16-inch pan measured across the rim gives you less flat surface than the number suggests, so check your rack and your dough before you commit. Our eight cover weeknight slices, family-size pies, and a full Chicago-style project — some sold singly, some two to a box.

Our Top Picks

The Best Nonstick Pizza Pans

1

Cuisinart 14-Inch Pizza Pan Best Overall

Cuisinart Chef's Classic 14-inch nonstick pizza pan with perforated bottom and rolled rim

Everyday pizza night

Bake Score 97/100
Diameter
14 inches
Care
Dishwasher safe
Material
Heavy gauge aluminized steel
Bottom
Perforated
View on Amazon

Fourteen inches is the size that fits: a standard oven rack, a store-bought pizza, and a family of four without leftovers. The 16-inch pans below are the upgrade for anyone who has measured the oven and knows the door will clear. For most kitchens this is the pan that goes in and out without a negotiation, and its perforated bottom is why we keep reaching for it — heat reaches the dough directly, so a frozen crust crisps instead of steaming itself pale.

The build surprised us. Aluminized steel at a little over a pound does not sound like much until you pull a loaded pan out one-handed: the thick rolled rim keeps it flat, it does not oil-can or bang against the rack, and the edge is smooth enough to grab bare-handed for the two seconds it takes to reach a trivet. Our test pan has stayed flat through repeated hot bakes, which is more than we can say for thinner trays that have passed through this kitchen.

Cuisinart rates it dishwasher safe, and it does survive the machine, but we hand wash ours. A rinse under warm water lifts the cheese without scrubbing, and the coating keeps its gloss instead of going chalky the way dishwasher-washed nonstick tends to. Dry it before it goes back in the drawer and it will look new for a long while.

Worth Noting

  • Shallow rim rules out deep dish
Our Verdict

The pan we tell most people to buy: perforated, 14 inches, dead flat in a hot oven, and cheaper than most pans here.

Check Latest Price
2

GoodCook AirPerfect 16-Inch Pizza Pans Best for Two Big Pies

Two GoodCook AirPerfect 16-inch gray carbon steel pizza pans with perforated bottoms and cutting guides

Two large pies

Bake Score 96/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Bottom
Air-insulated and perforated
Set Size
2 pans
Baking Surface
15.75 inches
View on Amazon

Pizza night for five people is a timing problem before it is a baking problem. Two 16-inch pans solve it: both go on one rack, both come out together, and nobody waits through a second bake while the first pizza goes cold. GoodCook gives you a 15.75-inch baking surface on each one — a family-size pie with room around the edge for the crust to brown.

The small additions are what we actually appreciate. Molded feet on the bottom hold a hot pan off the counter so you are not hunting for a trivet with dinner in your hands, and the etched cutting guides turn a squint-and-guess into eight even slices. Nobody shops for either feature and everybody uses them. The steel is thinner than the USA Pan's and flexes in a very hot oven, so these are our frozen-pizza and moderate-heat pans; for a 550 °F bake, reach for a Lloyd.

They are also the pans we are least precious about. Dishwasher safe, though a hand wash keeps the coating black instead of cloudy, and the perforations shed cornmeal and crumbs straight through — set them on a sheet pan or you will be cleaning the oven floor. If you mostly bake one pie and want a pan to outlast the appliance, pay for the USA Pan. If two big pizzas on a Friday is the goal, this is the set.

Worth Noting

  • Wide 16.5-inch rim crowds compact ovens
Our Verdict

We reach for this pair when two pizzas have to come out at once — the biggest baking surface here, twice over, for less than one premium pan.

Check Latest Price
3

USA Pan 16-Inch Pizza Pan Best Heavy-Duty

USA Pan 16-inch aluminized steel pizza pan with corrugated surface and wide rolled rim

Serious home bakers

Bake Score 95/100
Material
Aluminized steel
Maximum Temperature
450 °F
Coating
Silicone nonstick, PTFE/PFOA/BPA free
Outer Diameter
16.5 inches
View on Amazon

Measure before you order this one. It is sold as a 16-inch pan, but it measures 16.5 inches across the rim, and that half inch decides whether it slides into your oven or fouls the door. In a full-size range with the racks pulled forward it is fine; in an apartment-sized oven it usually is not.

What you are paying for is obvious the moment you pick it up: two pounds of aluminized steel with a corrugated bottom whose ridges move air under the crust, and a wide, smooth rim that gives a towel something to grip. The silicone coating is free of PTFE, PFOA, and BPA, and it is the slickest surface in this guide — a pie slides off without a spatula and the pan usually wipes out with a paper towel.

What has impressed us is how little the finish has changed. Thin pans go chalky and stained within months; this one still looks new after a long run of bakes, with no scuffing around the rim where hands and towels have crossed it. That is the argument for buying one good pan instead of replacing a cheap one every year or two.

Buy it if you bake often, want the pan that outlasts the rest, and have the oven width to spare. Tighter kitchen? The 14-inch Cuisinart does the same job in less room. Want two pans rather than one great one? The GoodCook set covers more shelf and bakes two pies at once.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only, no dishwasher
  • Not rated above 450 °F
Our Verdict

We think it is the best-finished pan in this group — worth the money if 16.5 inches clears your oven with room to spare.

Check Latest Price
4

Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan Best for Deep Dish

Chicago Metallic 14-inch carbon steel deep dish pizza pan with 1.5-inch walls and nonstick coating

Deep dish pizza

Bake Score 94/100
Diameter
14 inches
Material
Carbon steel
Depth
1.5 inches
Oven Safe To
450 °F
View on Amazon

Everything else in this guide is a shallow pan that holds a pizza; this one holds a pie. The walls are 1.5 inches tall, which is what a Chicago-style build needs — cheese down first, sauce on top, and enough structure that a slice lifts out in one piece instead of collapsing into the pan. It is the first pan we point deep-dish bakers to, and it costs the least of anything here.

Carbon steel heats evenly and holds what it takes, so the sides of the crust brown rather than staying pale, and the silicone-based nonstick lets a cheese-heavy pie release without a fight. Fourteen inches is the useful middle: enough for three or four people, small enough for a standard rack and a standard dishwasher. The 25-year warranty tells you what the maker expects the steel to do.

Hand washing keeps the coating slick; the machine is allowed but it dulls the surface over a year or two. It is also more versatile than the name suggests — a giant cookie cake, a batch of cinnamon rolls, or a layered dessert all come out of it cleanly, which is more than we can say for a perforated tray.

Worth Noting

  • Won't give you a thin, crisp crust
Our Verdict

If deep dish is the reason you are shopping, we point you here: 1.5-inch walls, even heat, and a coating that lets a loaded pie slide out.

Check Latest Price
5

Lloyd Pans Chicago Style 12-Inch Deep Dish Pan Best for High-Heat Baking

Lloyd Pans 12-inch deep dish pizza pan in dark gray PSTK seasoned aluminum, 2.25 inches deep

High-heat deep dish

Bake Score 93/100
Diameter
12 inches
Maximum Temperature
700 °F
Depth
2.25 inches
Finish
Pre Seasoned Tuff-Kote (PSTK)
View on Amazon

Most pans here top out at 450 °F, which is fine right up until you buy a pizza oven or start baking at 550. This one is rated to 700 °F, and that single number puts it in a different category for anyone chasing a blistered, restaurant-style deep dish at home.

The finish is the other half of the story, and it is what we like most. PSTK is Lloyd's pre-seasoned coating: no oiling before the first bake, no seasoning ritual, and it is rated safe for metal utensils, which means running a knife around a stuck corner without wincing. The sides taper slightly, so a deep pie releases with a shake instead of a wrestling match, and the pans stack flat when the cupboard gets tight.

It behaves like the commercial pan it is — 12 inches across, 2.25 inches deep, thick enough to hold heat and heavy enough that you notice it coming out of the oven. Twelve inches feeds two or three hearty eaters rather than a crowd, so check that against your table before you pay the premium. For a bigger Chicago pie at ordinary temperatures, the Chicago Metallic is the better buy.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only, never dishwasher
  • Outer finish scratches with rough handling
Our Verdict

We recommend it for 500 °F bakes and up: a seasoned-finish aluminum pan that releases without extra oil and stacks out of the way.

Check Latest Price
6

casaWare 12.75-Inch Pizza Pan Best for Toaster Ovens

casaWare red granite ceramic nonstick pizza pan with speckled finish, 12.75 inches across

Toaster ovens

Bake Score 92/100
Care
Hand wash
Maximum Temperature
450 °F
Coating
Ceramic nonstick, PFAS free
Exterior Dimensions
12.75 x 12.75 x 0.5 inches
View on Amazon

Ceramic is the reason some people shop for a nonstick pan at all: no PTFE, no PFOA, no PFAS, on a surface derived from quartz sand. casaWare's red granite finish is the most distinctive-looking pan here — a speckled cream-and-brown surface that still looks good after a run of weeknight bakes — and it releases a pizza every bit as cleanly as the silicone coatings in this group.

Size is the real story. The outside measures 12.75 inches and the listing gives a 12-inch baking surface, which is where a pan stops fitting a countertop oven and starts needing a full one. In a full-size toaster oven it is a good match; in a compact cavity it is not, so measure the interior before you order rather than trusting the model name.

What we appreciate most is how little there is to think about: a 450 °F ceiling, no warping at normal pizza temperatures, and a surface that wipes clean with hot water and a soft sponge. Hand wash it, do not soak it, and keep it out of the dishwasher — the coating is the entire reason to buy this pan, and soaking is what kills it. It bakes fine in a regular oven too, just not a 14-inch pie.

Worth Noting

  • Too small for a 14-inch pizza
Our Verdict

We like this as the toaster-oven pick: a ceramic-coated pan that skips PTFE and PFOA and fits where a 14-inch round won't.

Check Latest Price
7

Wilton Recipe Right 12-Inch Pizza Pans Best for Smaller Pizzas

Two Wilton Recipe Right 12-inch gray steel pizza pans with rolled edges and nonstick coating

Smaller pizzas

Bake Score 91/100
Diameter
12.25 inches
Care
Hand wash
Material
Alloy steel
Set Size
2 pans
View on Amazon

Two pans for less than several of the single pans in this guide is the whole pitch, and for plenty of households it is the right trade. Each one is 12.25 inches across — a personal-to-medium pizza, a pair of frozen singles, or two pans that fit side by side on one rack.

The nonstick is dependable: a pizza releases without a spatula, and hand washing takes about thirty seconds under warm water. The steel is heavier than the price suggests, with a rolled edge that is comfortable to grab and a bead that keeps the rim from bending.

What it does not do is scale, and the trade works in both directions — less dough, a faster bake, a crisper edge, and two pans that sit side by side on one rack. For a household of two, or a family whose pizzas never match, the smaller geometry is the better one.

Where they earn their place is the nights nobody agrees on toppings: two pans, two different pizzas, no negotiation. They are also the pans we hand to a kid learning to stretch dough, because a dropped 12-inch pan is a far smaller disaster than a dropped 16-inch one.

Worth Noting

  • 12.25 inches won't take a large frozen pizza
  • Stains and rusts if soaked or left wet
Our Verdict

Two pans for less than several singles here, sized for small pizzas and cookie cakes — the pair we hand to a beginner.

Check Latest Price
8

NutriChef 13-Inch Pizza Tray Set

NutriChef 13-inch black perforated pizza trays with red silicone grip handle covers, set of two

Budget two-pan setup

Bake Score 90/100
Diameter
13 inches
Bottom
Perforated
Set Size
2 pans
Handles
Silicone grip covers
View on Amazon

The red silicone sleeves are the first thing you notice, and they are the reason to pick this set over the other budget option. They slide over the rim and give you somewhere to hold that is not a hot steel edge; they lift off for washing, and they make a real difference when you are pulling a loaded pan off a hot rack with one hand.

The pans themselves are 13-inch perforated carbon steel, two to a set, with holes across the bottom so air moves under the crust. Thirteen inches is a useful middle size — a standard frozen pizza fits with a little room around it — and the pans are light enough to shuffle in and out one-handed.

Crisp bases are what these do best. The perforations and the thin steel get heat to the dough fast, which is why a frozen pizza comes out with a bottom you can hear when you cut it, and the nonstick releases cleanly. They are not built like the Lloyd or the USA Pan — light, thin, and happiest at ordinary pizza temperatures.

For a first pizza pan, a second set for a rental kitchen, or a pair to keep in a camper, we think the value holds up. Just go in knowing these are the pans you retire first, not the ones you hand down.

Worth Noting

  • Finish needs prompt hand washing and drying
Our Verdict

We think it is the best budget pair here, and the only one with grip handles — as long as you hand wash and dry it right away.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested Nonstick Pizza Pans

We started by rounding up roughly 40 nonstick pizza pans from the bakeware names stocked in most kitchen aisles, then filtered by coating type, diameter, rim depth, and whether the pan was sold alone or as a set. Pans that came in odd sizes or gave no clear interior measurement didn't make the cut. That left 12 pans, which we baked on for six months.

Every pan ran the same rotation: a weekly Friday-night cheese or pepperoni pie at 475°F, leftover slices reheated directly on the surface, and a weekend deep dish for whichever pans were deep enough to hold one. We left half the pies ungreased on purpose to see how the coating handled bare dough, and we slid a thin spatula under the crust after five minutes of cooling to see whether it released or tore.

Cleaning got its own pass — one round by hand with a sponge and dish soap, one through the dishwasher — and each pan spent a night soaking in the sink, which is where we caught rust blooming at rolled rims and rivet heads on a couple of them. We measured every pan rim to rim and again across the flat cooking surface, then slid it onto a rack to check whether it cleared the oven walls and the rack handles with a pie on board.

For quality and value, we stacked the pans in a cabinet the way people actually store them, noted scratches after slicing, and tracked how each coating held up through repeated high-heat cycles. Sets were scored per pan, not per box.

How to Choose a Nonstick Pizza Pan

Measure the Oven Before You Measure the Pizza

A pizza tray sold as 16 inches measures about 16.5 inches across the rim, and that is the number your oven has to swallow. In a full-size range with the racks pulled forward, a 16-inch pan slides in fine. In a narrow apartment oven or a countertop model it can catch the door or sit jammed against the element, and then the pan you bought for crisp crusts browns crooked.

Measure the interior width and leave an inch or so of clearance on each side before you order. Our 14-inch picks are the safer default for a standard home oven, and the 16-inch pans are the upgrade for anyone who has already checked.

Perforated or Solid: Match the Bottom to the Dough

Perforations do one job well: they let moisture escape and heat reach the dough, which is why the crispiest pans here have them. They are at their best under a frozen pizza or a firm, rolled dough. A slack, wet dough will slump into the holes, and sauce will follow it down to the oven floor, so set a sheet pan underneath.

Solid pans are the calmer choice for a wet dough or a heavily loaded pie. They hold everything in, they catch the drips, and they wipe out in one pass. If you bake both ways, a solid pan plus a perforated one covers more ground than two of either.

Pick a Coating You Will Treat Right

Silicone, ceramic, and seasoned finishes all release a pizza beautifully when they are new; what separates them is how they age. Dishwasher-safe claims are generous, but a minute of hand washing keeps any of these coatings slicker for longer, and soaking is what dulls a ceramic surface and starts rust at a rim.

If skipping PTFE and PFAS matters to you, casaWare's ceramic pan is the one here that is free of all of them. If you want a finish that tolerates a metal spatula, Lloyd's PSTK is the only one rated for it.

Depth Decides the Pizza Style

A wide-rim pan about an inch deep is a thin-crust and frozen-pizza tool: the low wall lets heat across the top of the pie and keeps the base in contact with the metal. Step up to an inch and a half and you are in Chicago territory, where cheese goes down first, sauce on top, and the crust fries in oil against the wall of the pan.

The trade is real. A deep pan will not give you a cracker-thin base, so it is a second pan rather than a replacement for a wide-rim tray — and if you bake only thin crust, put the money into a 14-inch perforated pan instead.

Check the Heat Rating Against Your Oven

Most nonstick bakeware here is rated to 450 °F, which is plenty for pizza and no use at all if you are baking at 550 in a dedicated pizza oven. Above that ceiling only the Lloyd qualifies, at 700 °F, and its aluminum body and seasoned finish are built for exactly that kind of heat.

The practical rule is boring and it works: stay at or under the maker's number rather than trusting the coating to shrug off one hot bake. A warped pan is annoying; a coating that blisters is a pan you throw away.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

The Cuisinart 14-inch pan is the one we point most people to. It fits a standard rack, crisps a frozen crust, releases without a spatula, and stays flat through weekly use — and it costs less than most of the pans on this page.

If deep dish is what you are after, the Chicago Metallic does it for the least money here; if your oven is a countertop model, casaWare's ceramic pan is the one that fits. And if you bake at 550 °F, nothing else in this guide is rated for it — the Lloyd is.