Wilton Recipe Right 12-Inch Pizza Pans Best Overall
- Diameter
- 12.25 inches
- Care
- Hand wash
- Max Temperature
- 450 °F
- Pans Included
- 2
Two pans come in the box, and the second one is most of the reason this set is our overall pick. Bake a pizza on one while the other holds a stretched dough, a batch of garlic knots, or the cookie cake you promised the kids; at 12-1/4 inches across with a shallow rim, it handles a supermarket frozen pie and a hand-stretched round with equal patience. For a household that makes pizza more than once a month, the pair removes the bottleneck a single specialty pan creates.
The nonstick does what nonstick is supposed to do. Crusts slide off rather than needing to be scraped, which matters most on the nights the dough is a little wet or the toppings have crept to the edge. Cleanup is a minute at the sink with warm water and a soft sponge, and the pan is rated to 450 degrees, covering the oven temperature most home pizza recipes call for.
It will not stay new-looking. The gray surface takes on a brown cast and picks up marks wherever a cutter crosses it. That wear is cosmetic, and we mind it far less than we mind paying twice as much for a single pan. The steel is sturdy enough to carry a loaded pizza without flexing, and Wilton backs the set with a five-year replacement warranty.
What We Like
- Two pans for the price of one specialty pan
- Reliable nonstick release, even with wet dough
- Even browning on frozen and fresh dough
Worth Noting
- Surface discolors and picks up cut marks
We recommend the Wilton set to most households: two reliable nonstick pans for less than one specialty pan, with the only real cost being a surface that stains.
Check Latest Price