Chicago Metallic 6 Cup Popover Pan Best Overall
- Cups
- 6
- Material
- Aluminized steel
- Oven Safe
- 450 °F
- Cup Size
- 2.75 x 2.25 inches
The first thing we noticed about the Chicago Metallic is how much space there is between the cups. That gap is not cosmetic: it lets hot oven air move around each well, so the batter climbs evenly instead of steaming in a crowded tray. We tested it with a hot pan and a fast pour, and the puddings came up with the kind of ragged, browned crown we want. For most people, this is the Yorkshire pudding pan to start with.
The six wells are 2.75 by 2.25 inches, which is deep enough to hold a generous pour without overflowing and narrow enough to force the batter upward. Aluminized steel is a sensible choice here: it heats quickly, stands up to a 450°F oven, and does not feel fragile when you pull a loaded pan out. The nonstick surface released cleanly in our tests, and the pan wiped out without a soak. A 25-year warranty is unusually generous for a pan at this price.
Against the Epica, the Chicago gives up some cup width but gains more space between wells, and that is the trade we prefer for an everyday pan. The Nordic Ware feels denser in the hand; the Chicago is easier to maneuver with one mitt. For the baker who wants one pan that does the job without fuss, this is the one we keep coming back to.
What We Like
- Wide gaps between wells improve airflow
- Deep 2.75 x 2.25-inch cups make tall puddings
- Budget price for a heavy-duty pan
- 25-year warranty backs the build
Worth Noting
- Hand washing recommended to protect the coating
- Cup rims are sharp enough to handle carefully
For most Yorkshire pudding bakers, this is the pan to buy: deep, separated wells give a tall, crisp rise, the steel heats evenly, and it costs less than most here.
Check Latest Price