The 7 Best Yorkshire Pudding Pans of 2026

Sunday roast is a lot of work to have the Yorkshire puddings come out flat. You rest the batter, you get the fat shimmering in the oven, and still half the cups puff into crisp shells while the rest sit there like pale pancakes. In my experience, that's rarely the recipe and almost always the pan — how thick the steel is, whether it holds heat evenly across every cup, and whether the surface lets go of the pudding in one piece.

We baked through 14 popover and Yorkshire pudding pans, and the difference between a good one and a flimsy one shows up fast. Heat retention is the biggest variable: a heavy pan stays hot when cold batter hits it, which is what lets the pudding climb, while a thin one drops temperature and hands you a greasy pancake. Cup size runs a close second, since a wider, deeper well gives the batter room to rise before it sets. Our seven aren't the prettiest we tried; they're the ones that rose.

Our Top Picks

The Best Yorkshire Pudding Pans

1

Chicago Metallic 6 Cup Popover Pan Best Overall

Chicago Metallic 6 Cup Popover Pan in black nonstick aluminized steel with six deep wells

Everyday tall puddings

Bake Score 95/100
Cups
6
Material
Aluminized steel
Oven Safe
450 °F
Cup Size
2.75 x 2.25 inches
View on Amazon

The first thing we noticed about the Chicago Metallic is how much space there is between the cups. That gap is not cosmetic: it lets hot oven air move around each well, so the batter climbs evenly instead of steaming in a crowded tray. We tested it with a hot pan and a fast pour, and the puddings came up with the kind of ragged, browned crown we want. For most people, this is the Yorkshire pudding pan to start with.

The six wells are 2.75 by 2.25 inches, which is deep enough to hold a generous pour without overflowing and narrow enough to force the batter upward. Aluminized steel is a sensible choice here: it heats quickly, stands up to a 450°F oven, and does not feel fragile when you pull a loaded pan out. The nonstick surface released cleanly in our tests, and the pan wiped out without a soak. A 25-year warranty is unusually generous for a pan at this price.

Against the Epica, the Chicago gives up some cup width but gains more space between wells, and that is the trade we prefer for an everyday pan. The Nordic Ware feels denser in the hand; the Chicago is easier to maneuver with one mitt. For the baker who wants one pan that does the job without fuss, this is the one we keep coming back to.

Worth Noting

  • Hand washing recommended to protect the coating
  • Cup rims are sharp enough to handle carefully
Our Verdict

For most Yorkshire pudding bakers, this is the pan to buy: deep, separated wells give a tall, crisp rise, the steel heats evenly, and it costs less than most here.

Check Latest Price
2

Epica Bellemain Popover Pan Best for Broad, Classic Puddings

Epica Bellemain six-cup popover pan in charcoal carbon steel with nonstick coating

Broad classic puddings

Bake Score 94/100
Cups
6
Material
Carbon steel
Oven Safe
450 °F
Cup Size
2.25 inches deep x 3 inches diameter
View on Amazon

The Epica's cups measure 3 inches across and 2.25 inches deep, a wider cylinder than you get on most six-cup pans. That extra width changes the shape of the bake: the batter has more room to spread before it climbs, so the finished pudding is broad and dramatic rather than narrow and delicate. The vertical walls also give it a clean line as it rises.

We like that shape for classic Sunday roast puddings, where a big, craggy top gives you more surface for gravy. In our tests, the nonstick released without a fight, and the carbon steel heated evenly enough that the six cups browned together. The wide rim gives you something to grip when the pan comes out hot. It is also dishwasher safe, which is a real convenience if you are making a batch on a busy day.

The Epica and the Chicago are close enough that the choice comes down to the shape you want. The Epica makes a broader cap with more surface for gravy; the Chicago makes a tighter, more even rise. We keep the Epica in the rotation for Sunday roasts and the Chicago for everyday batches. If you already know you want a wide, dramatic pudding, start here.

Our Verdict

For broad, dramatically puffed puddings, the Epica's wide 3-inch cups and reliable nonstick release make it a strong alternative to our top pick.

Check Latest Price
3

Nordic Ware Grand Popover Pan Best Heavy-Duty

Nordic Ware Grand Popover Pan in graphite cast aluminum with six deep cups

Heavy-duty browning

Bake Score 93/100
Cups
6
Material
Cast aluminum
Oven Safe
400 °F
Pan Dimensions
14.3 x 8.4 x 2.6 inches
View on Amazon

Cast aluminum announces itself the moment you lift the Nordic Ware Grand. At 16 ounces it is not the heaviest pan in this group, but the casting feels dense and solid, with none of the flex you get from thin steel. The graphite finish is dark and businesslike, and the six cups sit in a compact 14.3 by 8.4-inch frame that leaves room on the rack.

The pan is rated to 400°F, which is lower than the 450°F ceiling on several pans here. That matters because many popover recipes start hot. Check your recipe before you buy; if it runs at 425°F or 450°F, this is not the pan to use. The upside of the cast aluminum is steady heat and deep browning, and the nonstick surface released cleanly in our tests. It also has a straightforward, no-nonsense shape that is easy to rotate.

That cast-aluminum feel is what you are paying for, and it is worth it if you want a pan that browns with a steady hand and feels like it will outlast the novelty of a new hobby. It is not the value pick in this group; it is the one we choose when we want the pan to do some of the work.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only
Our Verdict

Choose the Nordic Ware when you want a heavy cast-aluminum pan that browns deeply and feels built to last; it is the substantial choice in this group.

Check Latest Price
4

Chicago Metallic Professional 6-Cup Popover Pan Best Nonstick Upgrade

Chicago Metallic Professional six-cup popover pan with metallic Armor-Glide nonstick coating

Easier nonstick release

Bake Score 92/100
Cups
6
Material
Aluminized steel
Oven Safe
230 °C
Cup Size
2.75 inches by 2.25 inches
View on Amazon

This is the same six-cup layout as our top pick, with one important change: the Armor-Glide coating. We noticed the difference most when releasing the puddings, which slid out with less encouragement than they did from the standard pan. The heavy aluminized steel still heats evenly, and the cups are the same 2.75 by 2.25 inches, so you get the same deep, tall shape. The metallic finish also wipes down more easily than a dark nonstick surface.

The Armor-Glide surface is the reason to choose this version. It gave us a cleaner release than the standard pan and felt a little more forgiving when the batter crept up the sides. Keep metal utensils away from it, and it should stay that way. For frequent bakers who want the same deep Chicago cups with a slicker finish, this is a sensible step up. It is not the bargain of the family, but it is the one we reach for when we want the least fuss at the moment of release.

Worth Noting

  • Costs more than the standard Chicago Metallic
  • Hand washing recommended to protect the coating
Our Verdict

For frequent bakers who want the easiest release in the Chicago family, the Armor-Glide coating makes these deep six-cup wells notably slicker.

Check Latest Price
5

USA Pan 6 Cup Nonstick Popover Pan Best for Hot-Pan Handling

USA Pan six-cup nonstick popover pan in silver aluminized steel with wide rims

Hot-pan handling

Bake Score 91/100
Cups
6
Material
Aluminized steel
Oven Safe
450 °F
Warranty
Limited lifetime
View on Amazon

The wide rim around the USA Pan's wells is the detail that stuck with us. It gives your mitt something to grab from any side, which matters when the pan is hot and the cups are full of batter. The fluted aluminized steel also looks and feels more substantial than a plain stamped tray, and the silver finish makes it easy to see when the edges are browning.

We like this pan for the physical part of baking: lifting, turning, and setting it down without feeling for an edge. The six wells are deep, the coating released cleanly, and the pan stayed flat in a hot oven. USA Pan makes it in Pittsburgh, which is a meaningful difference if domestic manufacturing matters to you. The commercial-grade steel is rated to 450°F, so it keeps up with a hot start.

The hand-wash-only care is the catch. That is not unusual for nonstick bakeware, but it is worth knowing before you buy. If you want a pan you can put in the dishwasher and still feel good about, the Epica is the easier choice. If you want the best handling in this group, the USA Pan is it.

Worth Noting

  • Premium price relative to other six-cup pans
Our Verdict

The USA Pan is for bakers who want a broad rim for oven-mitt handling and a sturdy American-made pan that feels solid in the hand.

Check Latest Price
6

Wrenbury Large Yorkshire Pudding Pan Best for Wide Roast-Dinner Yorkies

Wrenbury large Yorkshire pudding pan in black carbon steel with four wide cups

Wide roast-dinner Yorkies

Bake Score 90/100
Cups
4
Material
Carbon steel
Oven Safe
446 °F
Cup Width
4 inches
View on Amazon

Four cups, each 4 inches wide, is a very different promise from a six-cup pan. The Wrenbury is built for the kind of Yorkshire pudding that fills the middle of a plate and soaks up gravy, with a broad rim and a shallow, open well. At 10 by 10 inches, the pan also fits ovens and large oven-style air fryers that cannot take a 15-inch tray. The square shape gives you a little more room around each cup than a crowded six-cup frame.

The heavy carbon steel feels solid for its size, and the nonstick coating released cleanly in our tests. We especially like that the square footprint leaves room around the cups, so the edges can crisp without the pan crowding the oven walls. The 446°F rating and 10-year guarantee are both sensible for a pan used at roast-dinner temperatures. It is also easy to rinse, even before the fat has fully cooled.

Where this pan stops is the sky-high popover: the wide, shallow wells make a grand Yorkshire pudding, not a narrow, climbing crown. If you want that tall shape, choose one of the six-cup deep pans. For a roast dinner, four big puddings beat six delicate ones.

Worth Noting

  • Only four cups per batch
Our Verdict

Buy it for four wide, gravy-holding Yorkshire puddings and a compact oven or large air fryer; it makes roast-dinner-scale puddings with crisp edges.

Check Latest Price
7

Fox Run Non-Stick Popover Pan

Fox Run nonstick popover pan in grey carbon steel with six deep wells and wire frame

Budget airflow

Bake Score 89/100
Cups
6
Material
Carbon steel
Oven Safe
446 °F
Pan Size
15 x 9 x 2 inches
View on Amazon

The Fox Run's open wire frame is the first thing you see: the six cups sit in a metal cradle rather than a solid sheet. That design lets air move under and around the wells, and in our tests the cups browned evenly without a hot spot at the center. It also makes the pan look lighter and more open than a standard popover tray.

The steep-sided wells are the other half of the story. They are shaped to send the batter upward, and the nonstick coating let our test puddings release without a knife. The pan is 15 by 9 inches overall, so it takes up less width than some of the larger trays here while still holding six cups. The wire frame is easy to grip with a mitt, too.

We also appreciate the 446°F rating, which gives you room for a hot start, and the carbon steel does not feel thin or flimsy. It is a straightforward pan that does the job without extra bulk. The open design also means there is less solid metal to heat up, so the pan comes to temperature quickly.

For a budget pan, the Fox Run earns its place with the open frame and steep wells rather than a fancy finish. It does the job without asking for much counter space, and it is the pan we reach for when we want a second batch going without rearranging the oven.

Worth Noting

  • Nonstick coating can flake over time
Our Verdict

The Fox Run is a good budget pick for bakers who want an open wire frame and steep wells that let hot air reach the cups.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested the Best Yorkshire Pudding Pans

We started by pulling every popover and Yorkshire pudding pan we could find from bakeware brands we already trust, then narrowed by the things that actually decide the batch: the gauge of the steel, whether the cups were truly separated or stamped into one shallow tray, coating type, and cup dimensions. That left 14 pans, and each one got baked in rather than just unboxed.

Testing ran four months, mostly on Sunday afternoons and through two holiday dinners, which is when these pans earn their keep. I used the same batter every time — eggs, flour, and milk by volume, rested in the fridge — and heated each pan with beef drippings at 450°F before filling every cup to the same depth. Then I watched: did the puddings climb the sides evenly, did the back cups brown before the front ones, did any cup leave a soggy center.

Once they cooled, I turned each pudding out by hand before reaching for a spatula, then washed the pans by hand and in the dishwasher where the maker allowed it, scrubbing with a nylon brush to see whether the coating stained or scratched. Every few weeks I checked for wobble, warping, and rust at the seams. I also measured the cups and set two pans side by side on one rack to see what actually fits next to the roast.

How to Choose a Yorkshire Pudding Pan

Match the Well to the Rise

Deep wells, around 2 to 2.5 inches, hold more batter and force it upward, which is why a six-cup pan like our Chicago Metallic top pick gives such a tall, crisp crown. Wide, shallow wells make a broader pudding with more surface for gravy but less height; the Wrenbury's 4-inch cups are built for that roast-dinner style. A standard muffin tin is the wrong tool here because its wells are usually about an inch deep, so the batter spreads instead of climbing. Check cup depth before you fall for a pretty pan.

Choose a Cup Count That Fits Your Oven

Six cups is the practical sweet spot for most home ovens: you get a useful batch without a tray so wide it blocks heat or crowds a second rack. The Chicago and Epica pans both land in that range. A four-cup pan such as the Wrenbury is better for a small oven or a large oven-style air fryer; a two-pan set makes sense only if you regularly bake for a crowd and have the space. Measure your oven rack and air-fryer interior before choosing a 15-inch tray.

Read the Metal and the Temperature Rating

Aluminized steel heats quickly and is the most common choice here; cast aluminum, as on the Nordic Ware, holds heat with a heavier feel but often comes with a lower maximum temperature. Carbon steel is sturdy and responsive, and it is what both the Epica and Fox Run use. The number that matters is the pan's top oven temperature: if your recipe starts at 450°F, a pan rated to 400°F is the wrong match, no matter how well it browns. Choose a pan rated for your hottest recipe.

Plan for Nonstick Care and Handling

Nonstick is what makes deep wells release, but it is also the part that wears. Hand washing, avoiding metal utensils, and stacking the pan with a towel between it and the next tray will keep the coating working longer. Wide rims and sturdy frames are worth paying attention to if you use bulky oven mitts: the USA Pan's broad lips and the Fox Run's open wire frame are easier to grab than a slick, narrow tray. A good warranty helps, but careful handling matters more.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

Start with the Chicago Metallic 6 Cup Popover Pan. It offers the best balance of rise, release, and value in this group: deep, separated wells, even heat, and a finish that let our puddings out cleanly.

If you want a broader crown, the Epica's 3-inch cups are the better shape. For four wide, gravy-holding puddings or a compact oven, choose the Wrenbury. That is the real decision: tall and crisp, broad and classic, or wide and roast-dinner-sized.