Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet 2-Pack Best Overall
- Material
- Bare aluminum with encapsulated galvanized steel rim
- Set Includes
- 2 half sheets
- Usable Surface
- 17.1 x 12.1 inches
- Outer Dimensions
- 17.9 x 12.9 x 1 inches
Warping usually starts at the rim. When a cold pan hits a hot oven the floor heats faster than the walls, the metal has to expand somewhere, and on a thin stamped pan that somewhere is a rolled edge with nothing inside it — which is the pop you hear a few minutes into a batch of cookies. Nordic Ware runs an encapsulated galvanized steel core through the rim of the Naturals half sheet, and that band is why this is the pan we reach for first. The floor is bare aluminum, 17.1 by 12.1 inches, so standard half-sheet parchment and silicone mats drop in without trimming.
That combination — a stiff rim and uncoated aluminum — is what makes it the best all-around pan here. Aluminum moves heat into food faster than the alloy steel pans in this group, so cookies brown edge to edge and roasted vegetables come out blistered rather than steamed, and there is no coating to bubble, chip, or scorch at 450°F. We also like that there are two of them: one goes into the oven while the other cools on the rack, which is the rhythm most home baking actually runs on.
What you give up is a surface that stays pretty. Bare aluminum oxidizes into a mottled gray patina, sometimes after one batch of something acidic or one trip through the dishwasher, and it is not nonstick — a sugary glaze or a fried egg will weld itself on unless you line the pan or grease it. Neither changes how it bakes, and a paste of baking soda and water lifts the worst of the staining. Keep a roll of parchment next to the pans and you will stop thinking about it.
What We Like
- Steel-cored rim holds its shape in a hot oven
- Bare aluminum browns evenly with no coating to peel
- Two pans so one can cool while the other bakes
Worth Noting
- Not nonstick; parchment or a slick of oil earns its keep
- Bare aluminum dulls and stains with use
Two bare aluminum half sheets with a steel core in the rim: this is the pair we tell most people to buy, and the one that stays flat through high-heat roasting.
Check Latest Price