Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet Best Overall
- Material
- Pure aluminum
- Set Includes
- 2 half sheets
- Rim
- Encapsulated galvanized steel
- Exterior Dimensions
- 17.9 x 12.9 x 1 inches
Rust on a baking sheet almost never starts in the metal you can see. It starts in the steel under a coating, at the chip on a corner or the worn patch where you cut bar cookies, and by the time it shows it has been spreading for months. Nordic Ware's Naturals pans remove that failure point entirely: they are solid aluminum, uncoated, rim to rim. Aluminum does not rust, so there is no layer to scratch off and nothing to let moisture in. The only other metal on the pan is the encapsulated galvanized steel rim, and that is there to keep the sheet flat, not to keep it dry. That is why these earned the top spot.
Flat is the second half of the pitch. A thin pan that pops and twists when it hits a hot oven sends roasted vegetables sliding and browns cookies in a ring around the hot spots; the rolled, reinforced edge here is what stops that. Aluminum also conducts heat better than steel, which is why sheet after sheet comes out evenly browned rather than pale in the middle and scorched at the corners. We use ours for chocolate chip cookies, sheet-pan chicken with chickpeas, and a full pound of bacon.
The size is a true half sheet: 17.9 by 12.9 inches outside, 17.1 by 12.1 inside, with a 1-inch rim that holds a saucy dinner without turning into a roasting pan. Two pans also means one can be in the oven while the other holds the finished batch. If you want a pan that shrugs off a hot oven and a scouring pad alike, this is the one.
What We Like
- No coating to chip, so it cannot rust
- Encapsulated steel rim resists warping
- Two half sheets for less than our nonstick pick
Worth Noting
- Bare aluminum darkens and stains with use
- Not nonstick; parchment or oil is routine
Our default pick: solid aluminum has no coating to chip and nothing to rust, and the reinforced rim keeps both pans flat through high-heat roasting.
Check Latest Price