Nordic Ware Naturals Half Sheet 2-Pack Best Overall
- Material
- Aluminum with encapsulated galvanized steel rim
- Outer Dimensions
- 17.9 x 12.9 x 1 in
- Set Contents
- 2 half sheet pans
- Baking Surface
- 17.1 x 12.1 x 1 in
The rim is the first thing we look at on a sheet pan, and this one has an encapsulated galvanized steel rod running through the rolled edge. That rod is the reason a bare aluminum pan stays flat when it hits a 450-degree oven instead of popping and twisting halfway through a batch of cookies. Ours came through high-heat roasting and back-to-back cookie sessions without a bend. The size settles the rest: 17.9 by 12.9 inches outside, 17.1 by 12.1 inches of baking surface, which is the half sheet that clears a standard home range and takes ordinary parchment with no trimming.
Bare aluminum does the rest of the work. There is no coating to chip or flake, and heat moves through it fast enough that a tray of cookies browns edge to edge rather than in a hot ring around the middle. The surface dulls to a gray-brown as it ages, which we treat as patina rather than damage, and a baking soda paste lifts anything that cooks on. Wash it by hand and dry it right away; the dishwasher leaves bare aluminum chalky and streaked.
Two pans is the part that changes how you bake. Cookies need a cool sheet, so the second one keeps you loading the oven instead of standing there waiting for metal to cool. At 1.7 pounds apiece they are light enough to pull out one-handed with a full sheet of vegetables on them, and the lifetime limited warranty covers the manufacturing side. The one thing they will not do is release a sticky dough on their own, so keep parchment in the drawer.
What We Like
- Two half-sheet pans in one purchase
- Steel-reinforced rim resists warping at high heat
- Bare aluminum browns evenly with no coating to chip
- Light enough to handle one-handed when loaded
Worth Noting
- No nonstick surface, so sticky doughs need lining
- Stains and darkens with normal use
We make these the default pair: two bare aluminum half sheets with a steel-reinforced rim that stay flat at high heat and brown evenly.
Check Latest Price