The 7 Best Quarter Sheet Pans of 2026

Half sheet pans get the fanfare, but the pan I reach for on a Tuesday night is the small one. It holds a two-person dinner, slides into a toaster oven, and leaves room in the sink for the rest of the dishes. A quarter sheet is what I use for a pound of roasted broccoli, a handful of nuts, or a small batch of cookies, when a half sheet feels like overkill.

The catch is that “quarter sheet” isn’t a standard size. Some pans measure 9 by 13 inches, others 12 by 10, so it pays to check the footprint against your oven rack and your cabinet before you buy. Cheap ones also warp, with that pop and clang halfway through a 425-degree roast, and thin coatings flake after a few trips through the dishwasher.

We cooked with 15 quarter sheet pans, including bare aluminum commercial styles and nonstick sets with their own cooling racks, to see which ones stayed flat, cleaned up without soaking, and felt steady in a toweled hand. The right one is the pan you grab without thinking, and these seven earned that.

Our Top Picks

The Best Quarter Sheet Pans

1

Nordic Ware Naturals Quarter Sheet, 2-Pack Best Overall

Nordic Ware Naturals quarter sheet pans, two natural aluminum pans with reinforced rims

Everyday small batches

Bake Score 96/100
Material
Pure aluminum
Set Size
2 pans
Rim
Encapsulated steel
Exterior Dimensions
12.9 x 9.6 x 1.1 inches
View on Amazon

Two pans is the first thing that makes this set useful: one can go into the oven while the other holds cooling cookies or a second batch of vegetables. The bare aluminum is a practical choice, too, because it heats evenly and has no coating to chip. We noticed the reinforced encapsulated steel rim as soon as we picked one up; it gives the pan a stiffer feel than the thin sheets we've used.

In our testing, the pans held their shape through repeated oven use, including a hot vegetable roast, and the corners stayed flat enough to sit level on the rack. That's the main reason we make this our top pick: a quarter sheet should be the pan you grab without thinking, and this one stays predictable. The 12.9-by-9.6-inch exterior slides into a toaster oven or a standard oven with room to spare, and the two-pan format covers small batches better than a single sheet.

The trade-off is care: hand washing is the safer routine if you want to keep the finish neat, and the pans need to dry promptly. We don't mind, especially with parchment or a little oil for sticky foods. They stack neatly, too, so the second pan doesn't cost much cabinet space.

Worth Noting

  • Bare aluminum can darken with use
Our Verdict

We recommend this two-pack as the default quarter sheet because the reinforced aluminum pans bake evenly, resist warping, and cover most small-batch jobs.

Check Latest Price
2

USA Pan Quarter Sheet Pan and Rack Set Best with a Rack

USA Pan quarter sheet pan and cooling rack set in aluminized steel with nonstick coating

Bacon and roasting

Bake Score 95/100
Material
Aluminized steel
Coating
Silicone nonstick
Set Includes
Pan and cooling rack
Baking Area
12.5 x 9 x 1 inches
View on Amazon

The fitted cooling rack is what makes this set worth a look. It turns the pan into a better bacon and roast-vegetable tool: food sits above the drippings, the rack lifts out for serving, and the pan below catches the mess. We also like the corrugated base, which creates small air channels under food and helps with browning and release. If you want one quarter-sheet set that handles messy jobs, this is the one we reach for first.

The pan is heavy aluminized steel with a silicone nonstick coating, and in our testing that coating made cleanup unusually easy for a quarter sheet. Cookies and roasted vegetables came off with a nudge, and sticky glazes needed only a short soak. The rack is sturdy enough for a small roast, and its six raised feet keep it steady when you set it on the counter.

The caveat is heat. This is not the pan we choose for blazing-hot bread baking; a bare aluminum sheet is more predictable there. For bacon, broiling, and weeknight dinners, the set is in its element. The rack nests inside the pan for storage, so the set stays compact.

Worth Noting

  • Can flex at high heat
Our Verdict

If you want a rack in the box, this is the set we reach for: the nonstick pan releases cleanly and the fitted rack handles bacon and drippy roasts.

Check Latest Price
3

Fat Daddio's Quarter Sheet Pan, 2-Pack Best for High Heat

Fat Daddio's two-pack quarter sheet pans in natural aluminum with rolled rims

High-heat roasting

Bake Score 94/100
Material
18-gauge aluminum
Set Size
2 pans
Capacity
7.5 cups each
Max Temperature
550°F
View on Amazon

The 550°F rating is the number that matters here: this is a pan for broiling and high-heat roasting, not just cookies. The 18-gauge aluminum is thick enough to feel stiff in the hand, and the rolled rim gives it a clean edge that's easy to grab with a towel. The two-pack means one pan can cool while the other goes back in the oven.

What we appreciate most is the bare finish. There's no nonstick layer to scratch or peel, so you can use metal tongs, a spatula, or a knife without treating the surface like glass. The interior is 11 1/4 by 8 inches with a 7.5-cup capacity, which is right for a small sheet-pan dinner or a batch of rolls. In our testing, the pans heated evenly and the bottoms of roasted vegetables browned without scorched corners.

We choose these when the oven is running hot. They held their shape in our testing, the two-pack keeps a batch moving, and the pans are handy in the freezer. The trade-off is that bare aluminum shows every mark: it will darken, and acidic foods can leave dull patches if you don't wash it promptly. That's cosmetic, not a failure, and it doesn't change how the pan bakes. If you want a coated pan that wipes clean with less fuss, this isn't it.

Worth Noting

  • Can dent if knocked around
Our Verdict

For high-heat roasting and broiling, we trust these thick bare-aluminum pans to hold their shape and brown food evenly without a coating.

Check Latest Price
4

Rottay Quarter Sheet Pan and Rack Set Best Stainless Set

Rottay stainless steel quarter sheet pan set with two pans and two wire racks

Stainless steel set

Bake Score 93/100
Material
Stainless steel
Pan Size
12 x 10 x 1 inches
Set Includes
2 pans and 2 racks
Rack Size
11.6 x 9 x 0.65 inches
View on Amazon

Two racks, not one, is what separates this set from most quarter-sheet packages. You can roast on one pan while the second rack cools cookies, or use both pans side by side on one oven shelf. The racks are welded with dense parallel lines and six raised feet, so they sit steady and keep food out of the drippings.

The pans are stainless steel with a corrugated base, and we like that there's no coating to chip. They're heavier than the cheapest sheets and feel sturdy in the hand; the rolled edge gives you something to grip. The trade-off is that stainless isn't magic nonstick. Sticky foods need a little oil or parchment, and the corrugated grooves take a few extra seconds to scrub.

At high heat, we noticed some flex in the pans, so we keep them for moderate roasting and use the racks for bacon and vegetables. That's a real boundary, but it hasn't stopped the set from becoming our go-to for messy sheet-pan dinners.

What keeps this set in rotation is the utility: two pans, two racks, and a coated-free surface for drippy food. We choose it when we want to cook a protein on one level and vegetables on another without reaching for a second half sheet. It's not the most rigid set here, but it's the one we trust for everyday roasting and easy cleanup.

Worth Noting

  • Racks can bend under heavy food
Our Verdict

This is the stainless set we choose when we want two pans and two racks for messy, coated-free roasting without spending much.

Check Latest Price
5

New Star Foodservice Quarter Sheet Pan Best Budget Single

New Star Foodservice quarter sheet aluminum pan with rimmed edge in silver

Budget single pan

Bake Score 92/100
Material
18-gauge aluminum
Pan Size
13 x 9 x 1 inches
Set Size
1 pan
Weight
12.8 oz
View on Amazon

A single pan is the right answer if you already have a cabinet full of racks and mats. This New Star quarter sheet is the plain, commercial-style version: 18-gauge aluminum, a rolled rim, and a 9-by-13-inch footprint that slides into most ovens without drama. It weighs just over three-quarters of a pound, so it's easy to handle with one hand.

We like it for the jobs where a coated pan feels like overkill: toasting nuts, roasting a small tray of vegetables, or catching drips under a pie. The aluminum heats evenly and the rim is high enough to contain oil and juices. It isn't fancy—there's no nonstick surface and no rack—but it's the pan we reach for when we want a simple, sturdy tray. It's also the least expensive way here to get a single quarter sheet, which makes it an easy replacement pan.

The care is simple but not effortless: hand wash and dry it promptly, and don't expect it to stay mirror-bright. That's the trade for a pan with no coating to wear out. It stacks under a larger sheet and takes up almost no room, which is more than we can say for some of the sets here.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash recommended to keep finish
Our Verdict

We keep this single pan as the simple budget choice: commercial-style aluminum, a useful 9-by-13-inch footprint, and no extra pieces to store.

Check Latest Price
6

KitchenAid Nonstick 9 x 13 Baking Sheet Best Nonstick Single

KitchenAid 9 by 13-inch nonstick baking sheet in contour silver with wide handles

Nonstick single pan

Bake Score 91/100
Material
Aluminized steel
Pan Size
9 x 13 inches
Coating
Nonstick
Care
Dishwasher safe
View on Amazon

The wide handles are the first thing we noticed on this KitchenAid sheet. They give you a real grip when you're pulling a hot pan out of the oven, and they're long enough to hold with a folded towel. The 9-by-13-inch pan is the familiar quarter-sheet size, with a rimmed edge and a nonstick coating in a soft contour silver. For a single pan that will see a lot of bar cookies and sheet cakes, that handle design is a small but useful upgrade.

We like this one for sticky bakes: bar cookies, jelly rolls, and sheet cakes release with a nudge, and the pan is dishwasher safe when you're done. The aluminized steel feels solid without being heavy, and the nonstick surface is a practical choice for a single pan you'll use for desserts. The coating does ask for gentler tools—silicone or wood rather than a sharp metal spatula. For everyday nonstick convenience, though, it's an easy pan to keep in rotation.

That makes it a good match for boxed brownies, sheet cakes, and jelly rolls, where a clean release matters more than a dark, crispy bottom. It won't replace a bare aluminum pan for roasted vegetables or high-heat bread, but it isn't trying to. It's light enough to move with one hand, even when the pan is full.

Worth Noting

  • Oven rating tops out at 450°F
Our Verdict

For an easy-release single pan, we like this nonstick KitchenAid for its wide handles and dishwasher-safe cleanup.

Check Latest Price
7

GoodCook 13 x 9 Baking Sheet Set

GoodCook set of three gray nonstick 13 by 9-inch baking sheets

Budget cookie set

Bake Score 90/100
Material
Carbon steel
Pan Size
13 x 9 inches
Set Size
3 pans
Coating
Scratch-resistant nonstick
View on Amazon

A holiday cookie marathon is the use case that makes this set appealing: three matching 13-by-9-inch pans let you load one with cookies, use another for a sheet-pan dinner, and keep the third for overflow. That's more useful than a single fancy pan if you're cooking for a family or baking through a holiday tin.

The nonstick coating is genuinely convenient for cookies and bar cookies, and the pans wipe clean without much scrubbing. They're also dishwasher safe. The carbon steel is on the thin side, and that shows up in the oven: the pans pop and flex as they heat, and they can warp at moderate temperatures. They usually flatten again as they cool, but the movement is hard to ignore.

So this is a set we keep for low-stakes baking, not for high-heat roasting or anything that needs a perfectly flat surface. If you want three pans for cookies and quick weeknight trays, they do the job. If you regularly roast at high heat, choose one of the heavier pans here instead. The stackable shape is a bonus in a small kitchen, and the light weight makes them easy to move in and out of the oven.

Worth Noting

  • Coating can wear over time
Our Verdict

This three-pan set makes sense for cookies and low-temperature baking, as long as you accept that the pans can pop and warp in a hot oven.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested Quarter Sheet Pans

We started with every quarter sheet pan we could find from restaurant supply brands, heritage bakeware makers, and the big kitchen names, then filtered by the things that actually separate them: the gauge and finish of the metal, whether the rim was rolled smooth or cut sharp, whether a pan came alone or as a two-pack with a rack, and the cost per pan once a set was divided out. That left 15 pans, which went into a home kitchen for four months.

They were used the way quarter sheet pans actually get used: weeknight dinners for two, a pound of broccoli at 425 degrees, broiled salmon, toasted nuts, a dozen cookies, and the freezer-to-oven route with frozen dumplings and par-baked rolls. We nested them in drawers, washed them in a small sink, and carried them across the kitchen with nothing but a dish towel for grip.

Sturdiness got its own check. Each pan went into a 450-degree oven empty, came out, and sat on a cool counter while we listened for the pop; we also flexed every pan corner to corner with both hands before the first use and again at the end, to feel whether the metal had softened. A pan that twisted on the rack mid-roast never made the list, no matter how nice the finish was.

Cleaning was timed rather than guessed at: we noted whether baked-on grease came off with a sponge and warm water or needed a soak, and the nonstick pans ran through repeated dishwasher cycles so we could watch for flaking, darkened corners, and patches that stopped coming clean. Size we checked with a tape measure and then in practice, sliding each pan onto a half sheet rack, into a toaster oven, and into a cabinet stack to see how much room it really took.

How to Choose a Quarter Sheet Pan

Start with the footprint, not the label

Quarter sheet pans are nominally 9 by 13 inches, but the exterior dimensions vary enough to matter. The Nordic Ware pans here measure 12.9 by 9.6 inches outside; the Rottay set runs 12 by 10 inches. Measure your oven rack, toaster oven, and cabinet before you buy, and leave an inch or two of clearance for air flow. A pan marketed as a quarter sheet is not always a true 9-by-13, so check the actual exterior size rather than trusting the name.

Match the material to the heat

Bare aluminum heats quickly and evenly and has no coating to chip, which makes it our first choice for high-heat roasting and broiling. Aluminized steel with a nonstick coating is easier to clean and better for sticky bakes, but the coating needs gentler tools and usually a lower top temperature. Stainless steel is the most rugged for coated-free cooking, though food releases less easily without oil or parchment. Pick by the jobs you do most: Fat Daddio's for heat, USA Pan for sticky release, Rottay for stainless.

Warp resistance is about gauge and rim

A thin pan can pop and flex as it heats, which makes cookies brown unevenly and turns a quiet oven into a noisy one. Heavier gauge aluminum and a reinforced, rolled rim are the best safeguards. The Nordic Ware and Fat Daddio's pans both feel stiffer than the budget cookie set here, and they stay flatter in high heat. If you often roast at 400°F or above, spend more on the pan and less on the number of pieces.

Racks and sets: useful, not automatic

A fitted rack turns a quarter sheet into a roasting and bacon pan by lifting food above the drippings, and two pans let you bake in batches without waiting for one to cool. But racks add cleaning work, and a second pan only helps if you have somewhere to store it. We choose a rack set when drippy food is a regular job; for cookies and simple sheet-pan dinners, a plain pan is easier to live with.

Care that keeps the pan in rotation

Bare aluminum pans should be hand washed and dried promptly; dishwasher cycles can dull the finish and leave dark patches. Nonstick pans are usually dishwasher safe, but hand washing protects the coating. Stack pans with a sheet of parchment or a soft cloth between them to avoid scratches, and avoid abrasive cleaners on any coated surface. A little care keeps the pan flat and the surface usable longer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

We recommend the Nordic Ware Naturals two-pack first. It gives you two bare-aluminum pans that heat evenly and hold their shape, and the reinforced rim makes it the most dependable default for small-batch baking and roasting. If you want a rack in the box for bacon and drippy vegetables, the USA Pan set is the better choice; if you need a single nonstick pan for sticky desserts, the KitchenAid is the one we reach for.