Rottay Baking Sheet and Rack Set Best Overall
- Pan Size
- 16 x 12 x 1 in
- Set Contents
- 2 pans, 2 racks
- Material
- Uncoated stainless steel
- Rack Size
- 15.35 x 11 in
Two pans and two racks for about the same money as the two-pan P&P CHEF set here is what got our attention, and the racks are the part that keeps it. Each pan gets its own, so a tray of bacon can drain while the second sheet holds the vegetables, and there is no fishing a hot rack out of one pan to move it into another. At 15.35 by 11 inches the racks sit down inside the pan's rim rather than balanced across the top, which stops a roast from sliding when you pull the pan out.
The bottoms are corrugated, a detail we did not expect to care about. The ridges hold food slightly off the flat of the pan and let heat move underneath, so cookies release with less coaxing and roasted vegetables brown on the underside as well as the top. With the reinforced rolled edge the pans feel stiff in the hand, and the whole four-piece set runs about five pounds — light enough to pull one out one-handed when it is empty.
Racks are the weak point, and it is a fair trade rather than a surprise. They are thin wire, and a hot broiler will bow them; they flatten again by hand, so it is a chore rather than a problem. Cleaning the pans is the easy part — the polished surface wipes down with a sponge, and the grooves of the corrugated bottom are the only place food hides.
What We Like
- Two pans and two racks in one buy
- Racks sit inside the rim, so food stays put
- Corrugated bottom helps release and airflow
Worth Noting
- Pans can flex at 400°F and above
- Too large for compact countertop ovens
We recommend this set to anyone who wants two pans and two racks in one purchase — it covers everyday oven baking without a second shopping trip.
Check Latest Price