The 5 Best Deep Dish Pizza Pans of 2026

A deep dish pizza fails in exactly three ways: the bottom goes soggy, the crust welds itself to the pan, and the whole thing collapses the second you try to lift out a slice. All three are pan problems, not dough problems. The right pan holds two-plus inches of sauce and cheese without flexing, browns the crust against its walls instead of steaming it, and lets the pizza release in one piece.

We baked in 12 deep dish pans, everything from thin stainless steel to heavy anodized aluminum, and the pattern showed up within a few pizzas. Material and wall thickness matter more than whatever the nonstick label promises. Dark, heavy pans color the crust faster and hold their shape through a hot oven; light stainless ones release cleaner and shrug off the dishwasher but need a few extra minutes to brown.

Size is the other decision you only want to make once. A 12-inch pan is dinner for three or four, while the 14- and 16-inch pans feed a crowd and get genuinely heavy once they're loaded. All five survived repeated baking, scrubbing and a lot of molten cheese.

Our Top Picks

The Best Deep Dish Pizza Pans

1

Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan Best Overall

Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan, round silver carbon steel pan with a one-and-a-half-inch wall

Most home kitchens

Bake Score 96/100
Depth
1.5 in
Material
Carbon steel
Diameter
14 in
Oven Safe
450 °F
View on Amazon

Fourteen inches across, an inch and a half deep, and the least expensive pan here — that combination is why the Chicago Metallic is the one we point most people to first. Carbon steel heats evenly and holds that heat, so the base of a deep dish browns edge to edge rather than pale in the middle, and the silicone-based nonstick lets a heavy pie slide out whole even when cheese has crept to the rim.

What settled it for us was everything after the bake. At 1.8 pounds it is light enough to pull from a hot oven one-handed with a towel in the other, and the 450°F rating is more than a long, slow deep dish bake will ask of it. It is also dishwasher safe, which is the difference between making deep dish on a Tuesday and saving it for a weekend project, and a 25-year warranty sits behind it.

The 1.5-inch wall is the honest compromise. You get a thick, substantial crust, not the two-inch well a Chicago pizzeria works with, so a full cheese-first build needs a slightly smaller dough ball or the filling rides over the edge. Treat the coating well — nylon server instead of a wheel, hand wash when you have the patience — and it keeps releasing cleanly far longer than the money would suggest.

Worth Noting

  • 1.5-inch wall is shallower than a true Chicago pan
Our Verdict

Our pick for most kitchens: it browns evenly, releases a heavy pie, and cleans up in the dishwasher for less than any other pan here.

Check Latest Price
2

Lloyd Pans Chicago Style Pizza Pan Best for True Chicago Depth

Lloyd Pans 16-Inch Chicago Style Pizza Pan in dark gray aluminum with a deep wall

Authentic Chicago depth

Bake Score 93/100
Depth
2.25 in
Material
Aluminum
Outer Diameter
16.62 in
Capacity
402 cu in
View on Amazon

If the point is the pie you get in Chicago, this is the pan to buy. Lloyd's 16-inch model is 2.25 inches deep, and the wall tapers slightly outward, so a full stack of cheese, sausage, and crushed tomato sits inside the crust instead of spilling over it, and a loaded wedge lifts out with a thin spatula rather than tearing away from the side.

The finish is the other thing you are paying for. It arrives pre-seasoned in Lloyd's PSTK finish, so there is no oiling-and-baking cycle before the first pie, and it is rated safe for metal utensils, which means cutting and serving can happen right in the pan. Set beside a coated pan, the surface reads as part of the metal rather than a layer sitting on top of it.

Sixteen inches is a lot of pizza. A deep dish that size is a table-of-friends pie, and filling it takes a real quantity of dough, cheese, and sauce — this is not the pan for a two-person weeknight. It does stack, so storage and dough proofing both work, and at 1.9 pounds it stays manageable going in and out of the oven.

Worth Noting

  • Finish can show scratches, including out of the box
  • Hand wash only to protect the coating
Our Verdict

Buy this one if you want the real Chicago well: 2.25 inches deep, tapered for release, and pre-seasoned straight out of the box.

Check Latest Price
3

Elsjoy 4 Pack Deep Dish Pizza Pan Best for Baking a Batch

Elsjoy 13-inch stainless steel deep dish pizza pans, four-pack of round silver nonstick trays

Baking several pies

Bake Score 90/100
Depth
2 in
Outer Diameter
13 in
Pack Count
4
Inner Diameter
11 in
View on Amazon

Thirteen inches is the outside of this pan; the surface your dough touches is 11 inches across. That second number is the one that decides your pizza, and it makes each pan in the four-pack smaller than the 12-inch Chef Pomodoro and well short of a 14-inch pan. What you are buying instead is quantity: four pans, dishwasher safe, that nest into one shallow column in a cabinet.

The stainless body is thicker than the money would suggest — these hold their shape through a hot oven without the oil-canning thin trays develop. We ran them as a set of smaller pies rather than one showpiece, and the 2-inch wall gives a proper well; a brown-edged crust came away without a fight. Cleanup is the best part: a soak, a wipe, done.

Our recommendation is narrow and specific. This is the set for a party, a freezer stash, or a family that argues about toppings, since four 11-inch pies go in together and come out already portioned. For one large deep dish to set on the table, the size math works against it and a single 14-inch pan is the better buy.

Worth Noting

  • Only 11 inches of actual baking surface
Our Verdict

We recommend the four-pack for batch baking and freezer pies, not for the one big showstopper deep dish.

Check Latest Price
4

Chef Pomodoro Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Pan Best for Small Kitchens

Chef Pomodoro 12-inch Chicago deep dish pizza pan in dark gray hard-anodized aluminum

Small kitchens

Bake Score 89/100
Depth
2 in
Material
Hard-anodized aluminum
Weight
11.8 oz
Diameter
12 in
View on Amazon

Twelve inches across and 2 inches deep is the size to look at if your oven is small, your counters are full, or your household is two people and a dog. There is enough wall for a real deep dish well, and it still fits a narrow rack that a 14- or 16-inch pan would crowd.

Hard-anodized aluminum explains why it bakes as well as it does at this size — it moves heat quickly and evenly, so a 2-inch-deep pie sets through without the rim scorching before the middle is done. It is also light at 11.8 ounces, which sounds trivial until you are pulling a pan full of cheese and sauce out of a hot oven at arm's length.

Pre-seasoned from the factory, it bakes the first pie without a prep step, and the release has held up on a cheese-heavy build. The trade is capacity — a 12-inch deep dish feeds three comfortably, four with a salad alongside — and there is no stretching it for a bigger table. For a small kitchen, that is the right trade.

Worth Noting

  • Feeds three or four, not a crowd
Our Verdict

A compact 12-inch pan that bakes a proper 2-inch deep dish; we like it best where oven space is tight.

Check Latest Price
5

BEENIFIC Stainless Steel Deep Dish Pizza Pan Best for Coating-Free Baking

BEENIFIC 14-inch stainless steel deep dish pizza pan with a bright uncoated finish

Coating-free baking

Bake Score 88/100
Material
Food-grade stainless steel
Weight
14.5 oz
Oven Safe
480 °F
Size
14 x 1.8 in
View on Amazon

There is no coating on this pan, and for plenty of cooks that is the entire argument. It is food-grade stainless steel with nothing to flake, blister, or wear through, and it is rated to 480°F, which covers any deep dish bake you are likely to run.

We were skeptical about release from bare metal, and it is the honest trade: nothing here pretends to be nonstick. A deep dish recipe already calls for a few tablespoons of oil in the bottom of the pan, and that plus a properly preheated oven is what lets the crust lift away. Where it earns its place is longevity — with no finish to baby, a metal server and a dishwasher cycle cost you nothing.

Fourteen inches across with a wide rim, it is the easiest pan here to move in and out of the oven, because there is real metal to grab with a mitt. At roughly 14.5 ounces it is lighter than the carbon steel pan and far lighter than a loaded skillet. The listed size is 14 by 1.8 inches, which puts the wall above the Chicago Metallic's and below the Lloyd's.

Worth Noting

  • Bare steel needs oil in the pan for release
Our Verdict

Pick this one if you want no coating to wear out: bare stainless that shrugs off metal utensils and the dishwasher.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested the Deep Dish Pizza Pans

We started with every deep dish pan we could find that had straight walls at least 2 inches tall, then narrowed the field by material, diameter, coating type, and handling. Pre-seasoned steel, hard anodized aluminum, and bare stainless all made the cut. Twelve pans, in sizes from 10 to 16 inches, went into home kitchens for eight months.

Each pan got the same workout: a full Chicago-style build, with oil or butter in the bottom, dough pressed up the walls, cheese, sausage, and crushed tomatoes on top, baked at 425 to 450 degrees for 35 to 45 minutes. We watched for the things that ruin a deep dish. Did the crust slide out in one piece under a thin spatula, or tear at the corner? Did the bottom brown or steam? Did the pan pop or flex when it hit a hot rack?

Then came the unglamorous part. Each pan cooled with the baked-on cheese and sauce still in it, soaked for 20 minutes, and was washed by hand, and half of them ran through the dishwasher on repeat to see what happened to the finish. We stacked them in a cabinet to check whether they nested or scratched, lifted each one loaded with a full pizza, and checked whether the rim was wide enough to grip with mitts.

We also scored each crust in the pan with a knife to see how the coating held up, and tried the pans for the casseroles and pies a few of them are sold for. Eight months in, the keepers still release cleanly and sit flat. The ones that didn't make it warped or started flaking by the fourth bake.

How to Choose a Deep Dish Pizza Pan

Depth Decides the Style

Plenty of pans sold as deep dish have walls around 1.5 inches, which makes a substantial thick-crust pizza — the Chicago Metallic here is one of them. A true Chicago-style pizza pan runs 2 to 2.25 inches so the cheese, the toppings, and a wet layer of crushed tomato all sit down inside the crust. Neither is wrong; they are different pies. Decide which one you are actually cooking before you compare anything else.

The trap is the unlabeled pan. A pan advertised as deep dish with no depth anywhere in the specifications is usually a 1-inch pizza pan with a marketing problem, and no amount of dough turns it into a deep dish pan. If the depth is not stated, keep looking.

The Inner Diameter Is the One That Bakes

A 13-inch pan with thick walls can leave you 11 inches of actual surface, which is what the Elsjoy four-pack does — that inch on every side is crust, not pizza. Compare inner diameters where they are published, and expect usable area to shrink as the wall gets taller.

Then check the oven. A 16-inch pan measures close to 17 inches across the rim and needs clearance from the oven walls as well as the door swing. Measure the rack width and the interior depth of the oven, not just the rack, before you go bigger than 14 inches.

Coated, Pre-Seasoned, or Bare Steel

Nonstick coatings give the easiest release and the shortest working life: they do not want metal utensils or harsh dishwasher cycles. A pre-seasoned finish, like the one on the Lloyd pan, is tougher and rated for metal, but it is a hand-wash item. Bare stainless, like the BEENIFIC, has nothing to wear out at all — you supply the release with oil in the bottom of the pan, which deep dish recipes call for anyway.

Our preference is to match the surface to how you cook. An occasional baker gets more from a coated pan that goes in the dishwasher; anyone chasing a clean release every week should pay for the pre-seasoned finish.

Weight and Rim Grip Matter More Than You Think

An empty pan weighs anywhere from about 11 ounces to nearly two pounds; fill it with dough, cheese, and sauce and it becomes a two-handed lift. A wide, defined rim gives you somewhere to grab with a mitt, and a shallow lip on a heavy pan is how deep dish ends up on the oven floor.

Stacking is the other half of that question. Straight-sided pans nest only when they are empty and dry, and a 16-inch pan claims most of a shelf. Tight on cabinet space? A nesting set, or a pan that doubles as a dough-proofing bowl, earns its keep.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

Most people should buy the Chicago Metallic. It browns evenly, releases a heavy pie without a fight, goes in the dishwasher, and does it for less than anything else here. The 1.5-inch wall makes a thick-crust deep dish rather than a true Chicago well, and that is the only real compromise in the pan.

If the true Chicago well is the point, spend for the Lloyd Pans 16-inch: 2.25 inches deep, tapered so a loaded wedge lifts clean, and pre-seasoned so it is ready the day it arrives. The choice comes down to which pie you are actually going to bake.