Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan Best Overall
- Depth
- 1.5 in
- Material
- Carbon steel
- Diameter
- 14 in
- Oven Safe
- 450 °F
Fourteen inches across, an inch and a half deep, and the least expensive pan here — that combination is why the Chicago Metallic is the one we point most people to first. Carbon steel heats evenly and holds that heat, so the base of a deep dish browns edge to edge rather than pale in the middle, and the silicone-based nonstick lets a heavy pie slide out whole even when cheese has crept to the rim.
What settled it for us was everything after the bake. At 1.8 pounds it is light enough to pull from a hot oven one-handed with a towel in the other, and the 450°F rating is more than a long, slow deep dish bake will ask of it. It is also dishwasher safe, which is the difference between making deep dish on a Tuesday and saving it for a weekend project, and a 25-year warranty sits behind it.
The 1.5-inch wall is the honest compromise. You get a thick, substantial crust, not the two-inch well a Chicago pizzeria works with, so a full cheese-first build needs a slightly smaller dough ball or the filling rides over the edge. Treat the coating well — nylon server instead of a wheel, hand wash when you have the patience — and it keeps releasing cleanly far longer than the money would suggest.
What We Like
- Even edge-to-edge browning on carbon steel
- Nonstick release under a heavy cheese load
- Dishwasher safe and light to lift
Worth Noting
- 1.5-inch wall is shallower than a true Chicago pan
Our pick for most kitchens: it browns evenly, releases a heavy pie, and cleans up in the dishwasher for less than any other pan here.
Check Latest Price