The 8 Best Donut Pans for Baking of 2026

A lazy Sunday batch of cider donuts sounds perfect until you're chiseling one out of the pan. The difference between a joyful morning and a sink full of scrubbing usually comes down to the pan: how evenly it bakes, whether the batter releases cleanly, and whether the thing still sits flat after a few trips through the oven. A good donut pan turns a finicky project into a repeatable habit; a bad one makes you wonder why you didn't just drive to the shop.

I've baked with 14 donut pans and sets, from flimsy silicone molds to heavy steel six-cavities. I made cake donuts, yeasted rings, and a few experimental bagel-shaped things, then washed every pan by hand and ran the dishwasher-safe ones through a full cycle. Size turned out to matter more than I expected—a 20-cavity pan is great for a crowd but a beast to store—and the cheapest pans were often the ones that warped or stuck.

Our Top Picks

The Best Donut Pans for Baking

1

Wilton Gold Donut Pan Set Best Overall

Wilton Gold two-piece nonstick donut pan set with two gray six-cavity pans

Everyday baking

Bake Score 97/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Coating
PFAS-free nonstick
Oven Safe
450°F
Pans Included
Two 6-cavity pans
View on Amazon

A dozen is the batch most recipes make you bake in two rounds with a six-cavity pan. The Wilton Gold set solves that with two six-cavity pans, and that practical head start is why it is our top pick. Both pans are oven safe to 450°F, the nonstick coating is made without PFAS, and they are dishwasher safe. We also appreciate the extended handles when a loaded pan comes out of the oven.

The coating is the part that matters day to day. Baked donuts are delicate, and a pan that grips them ruins the fun; these rings release cleanly with a light coat of cooking spray and keep their shape. The wells are shallow, so fill them about two-thirds full and use a piping bag or a zip-top with the corner cut for the neatest ring. Overfilling is the one mistake that turns a donut into a muffin top.

Dishwasher-safe is a real convenience, though we still hand wash and dry the pans most of the time to keep the coating in good shape. For a commercial-style pan, the USA Pan or Bellemain is the step up. For everyday baking, though, the two-pan set is the one we reach for first.

Our Verdict

We think the Wilton Gold set is the best everyday choice: two six-cavity pans, reliable release, and dishwasher-safe cleanup make a full dozen simple.

Check Latest Price
2

Bellemain Donut Pan Set Best Heavy-Duty Metal

Bellemain two-pack gray nonstick steel donut pans with six cavities each

Heavy-duty home baking

Bake Score 96/100
Care
Hand wash only
Material
Premium steel
Coating
Nonstick
Pans Included
Two 6-cavity pans
View on Amazon

Bellemain's set is built for the baker who wants metal pans with a little more heft than the usual budget pair. You get two six-cavity pans with a nonstick coating and a premium-steel body, and the wells are shaped for cake donuts and bagels. The shape is familiar: fill, bake, cool, and flip.

What earns it a runner-up spot is the balance of strength and release. The steel body holds its shape when you move a loaded pan, while the nonstick surface lets the rings drop out without a struggle. We prefer it for frequent bakers who want a pan that feels solid in the hand and do not mind a little extra care.

Two pans make a dozen, which is the right format for most recipes. If you already own one good metal pan and only need a spare, this set is more than you need; if you are starting from scratch and want a sturdier feel, it is a sensible upgrade.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only
Our Verdict

We recommend the Bellemain set when you want a more substantial metal pan and can live with hand washing.

Check Latest Price
3

Wilton 20-Cavity Donut Pan Best for Big Batches

Wilton 20-cavity nonstick steel donut pan with a large rectangular frame

Big-batch parties

Bake Score 95/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Cavities
20
Overall Size
21.5 x 15.5 x 0.8 inches
Cavity Diameter
3.25 inches
View on Amazon

Twenty cavities is not a gimmick if you bake for a crowd; it is the difference between one batch and an afternoon of rotating trays. Wilton's mega pan turns out 20 standard 3.25-inch donuts at once, and the nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe cleanup make the aftermath manageable. We like it for school events, brunches, and any morning when the whole family wants a second donut.

The pan measures 21.5 by 15.5 by 0.8 inches, so it takes up serious oven real estate. Check your rack and door clearance before you commit; it fits standard ovens, but it leaves little room for a second pan. That is the trade for getting the whole batch done in one pass.

The wells are shallow enough that a generous pour can close the hole, so keep the batter below the rim. And because the pan makes so many at once, have your cooling rack and glaze station ready before it comes out of the oven. It is a specialized tool, but it does its one job very well.

Our Verdict

For a crowd, we reach for the 20-cavity Wilton because it turns a single recipe into a full party batch.

Check Latest Price
4

USA Pan 6-Well Donut Pan Best Splurge

USA Pan six-well aluminized steel donut pan with a silver corrugated surface

Premium baking

Bake Score 94/100
Material
Aluminized steel
Coating
PTFE, PFOA, and BPA-free silicone
Wells
6
Well Size
3.5 x 3.38 x 0.88 inches
View on Amazon

USA Pan is the premium choice here, and the money goes into construction rather than decoration. The aluminized steel is commercial grade and heavy gauge, with a corrugated surface designed to circulate air and a silicone coating that is free of PTFE, PFOA, and BPA. It is a six-well pan, not a two-pack, and it carries a lifetime warranty.

The substantial feel is the point: the heavy-gauge steel sits flat and resists warping, and the corrugated surface is meant to encourage even browning. The wells are a useful size for a substantial ring, but this is still a one-pan purchase: you get six donuts per batch.

The long view is what justifies the splurge: one heavy pan that resists warping and carries a lifetime warranty is the kind of bakeware you stop thinking about. For occasional donut making, it is more pan than necessary; for a kitchen where bakeware gets used hard, the build earns its keep.

Worth Noting

  • Hand wash only
Our Verdict

We see the USA Pan as the splurge for a baker who wants one heavy-duty six-well pan and a lifetime warranty.

Check Latest Price
5

NutriChef Donut Pan Set Best Budget Metal

NutriChef two-pack black carbon steel donut pans with six cavities each

Budget metal set

Bake Score 93/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Material
Carbon steel
Oven Safe
450°F
Pans Included
Two 6-cavity pans
View on Amazon

NutriChef's two-pan set is the budget metal pick: it gives you a dozen cavities, a carbon-steel body, and a nonstick coating without the premium price. The pans are oven safe to 450°F and dishwasher safe, and the coating is free of PFOA, PFOS, and PTFE. For a first set or a holiday backup, that combination is hard to argue with.

What we like is that the low price does not come with a flimsy, single-use feel. The carbon steel is rigid, the nonstick surface releases cleanly when the wells are greased, and the two pans give you room to work. It is not as refined as the USA Pan, but it covers the basics for a fraction of the cost.

The two-pan format is the real win, since you can bake a full dozen and still have a pan free for the next round. If you bake only a few donuts at a time, a single pan takes up less space; if you regularly make a dozen, this set is the practical buy.

Worth Noting

  • Shallow wells can overflow
Our Verdict

We consider NutriChef the budget metal set to beat when you want a dozen cavities without a premium badge.

Check Latest Price
6

Walfos Silicone Donut Pans Best Silicone

Walfos set of three flexible silicone donut molds in multicolor

Easy-release silicone

Bake Score 92/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Material
Food-grade silicone
Molds Included
Set of 3
Heat Resistance
Oven safe to 446°F
View on Amazon

Silicone is the right material when release is the part of donut baking you dread. Walfos sells a set of three food-grade silicone molds that are BPA-free, dishwasher safe, and rated for oven use up to 446°F. The molds flex, so a baked donut comes out with a gentle push from underneath rather than a knife around the edge.

The set gives you more than one mold, so you can keep a batch moving while another cools. The silicone is soft enough to stack or fold into a drawer, which matters in a small kitchen. We also like that cleanup is a rinse or a dishwasher cycle rather than a soak.

It will not give you the dark, crisp edge of a metal pan, and the rings stay pale even when they are fully baked. That is the trade for release that rarely fails and storage that takes almost no space. For tender rings and easy release, it is the silicone set we reach for; do not expect bakery-style browning.

Worth Noting

  • Needs a baking sheet for support
Our Verdict

We choose the Walfos silicone set when easy release and flexible storage matter more than a browned crust.

Check Latest Price
7

CHEFMADE 12-Cavity Donut Pan Best Single-Pan Dozen

CHEFMADE 12-cavity carbon steel donut pan in champagne gold

Single-pan dozen

Bake Score 91/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Material
Carbon steel
Cavities
12
Oven Safe
428°F
View on Amazon

A dozen cavities in one pan is a different kind of convenience from a pair of six-cup pans. CHEFMADE's 12-cavity ring mold is made from thickened carbon steel, rated to 428°F, and finished in a champagne gold nonstick coating that is free of PTFE and PFOA. It fits into the oven as one piece and comes out as one tray to clean.

The nonstick surface releases cleanly, and the gold finish is handsome enough that we do not mind leaving it out between bakes. It is also easy to store for its capacity, and the coating wipes clean without a long soak.

It is a home baker's tool rather than commercial equipment, so use a light hand with metal utensils and avoid abrupt temperature changes. The carbon steel heats evenly, and the strengthened edge helps it hold its shape.

What we like most is the one-tray rhythm: fill, bake, glaze, done, with no second pan waiting for space. It makes a dozen without turning the kitchen into a production line.

Worth Noting

  • Makes smaller donuts than standard pans
Our Verdict

We like CHEFMADE's 12-cavity pan for bakers who want a dozen smaller donuts from one attractive tray.

Check Latest Price
8

Aichoof Silicone Donut Pans Best for Air Fryer Use

Aichoof set of three gray silicone donut molds with six cavities each

Air fryer use

Bake Score 90/100
Care
Dishwasher safe
Cavities
6 per mold
Molds Included
Set of 3
Heat Range
-22°F to 446°F
View on Amazon

Aichoof's silicone set is the one we point to when the oven is not the only appliance in play. The three molds are BPA-free, rated from -22°F to 446°F, and safe for the oven, microwave, freezer, air fryer, and dishwasher. That breadth is useful in a small kitchen, where one mold can go from air-fryer batch to freezer storage without a second pan.

Each mold has six 3-inch cavities, so the set is more about rotations than one giant batch. The silicone releases donuts easily, and cleanup is a rinse or a dishwasher cycle. We like the set for toaster-oven and air-fryer users, but check the 10-by-7-inch footprint against your basket before you count on it fitting.

The trade-offs are the familiar silicone ones: a loaded mold needs support, and the rings will stay pale rather than crisp. That makes the set a good fit for delicate cake donuts and a poor fit for anyone chasing a fried-style crust.

The set's real advantage is rotation: one mold bakes while another cools, and the third is already filled. For a small kitchen, that rhythm is the reason it earns cabinet space.

Worth Noting

  • Runs smaller than expected
Our Verdict

We suggest Aichoof's silicone set for air-fryer and small-oven bakers who want flexible, easy-release molds.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested the Donut Pans

We started by pulling together a shortlist of 14 metal and silicone donut pans in six-, twelve-, and twenty-cavity sizes, filtering out models with vague coating claims or dimensions that wouldn't fit a standard sheet pan. We also weighed price against what you actually get—a two-pack of thin steel pans costs less than one sturdy pan, but not if both warp by February. Over four months, I baked in each pan at least three times, using the same cake donut batter and a looser yeasted dough so I could compare release and browning without blaming the recipe.

Most testing happened on weekend mornings when my family expects donuts, plus a few rushed weekday batches before school. I filled each cavity with the same scoop, checked whether the batter spread evenly, and noted if the tops browned before the centers set. After cooling, I turned the pan over and counted how many donuts dropped out cleanly; the rest got a gentle nudge with a silicone spatula. Then I washed each pan by hand with a soft sponge, scrubbing any stuck rings, and ran the dishwasher-safe ones through a full cycle to see if the coating dulled or the edges rusted.

I also tested size and storage: whether a pan fit in a drawer, whether a silicone mold needed a sheet pan underneath for stability, and whether a 20-cavity pan was worth the cabinet space. To check durability, I stacked pans the way I actually store them and looked for flex, scratches, and warping after repeated heating. The pans that scored best released donuts without a fight, cleaned up in under a minute, and still sat flat after four months of use.

How to Choose a Donut Pan for Baking

Batch Size and Oven Fit

Six cavities is the standard single-pan size, and it is enough for a small household or a test batch. A 12-cavity pan or a two-pan set makes a full dozen in one go, but check the overall dimensions, not just the cavity count: a 20-cavity pan is a full-sheet-sized piece of equipment. Measure your oven rack and door clearance before buying a mega pan. If you often bake a dozen, a pair of six-cavity pans is more flexible than one 12-cavity tray because you can use one or both.

Metal or Silicone?

Metal pans give baked donuts a firmer edge and more browning, and they hold their shape when you move a loaded tray. Silicone molds release delicate rings easily and fold away for storage, but they need a baking sheet underneath and produce a paler, softer crust. Choose metal if you want a substantial pan and bakery-style color; choose silicone if easy release and small-kitchen storage matter more. A doughnut pan is not a fryer, so neither material will give you a crisp fried shell.

Cavity Size and Depth

Most standard baked-donut pans have cavities around 3 to 3.5 inches across, but the hole size and depth vary. A large center hole can leave a thin ring that breaks when you lift it; a shallow well can overflow and close the hole. If you want big, substantial donuts, look for a full-size cavity and fill it no more than two-thirds full. Smaller 3-inch cavities are fine for snack-sized rings, lunchboxes, and kids, but they will not satisfy a bakery-size craving.

Coating, Cleaning, and Longevity

Nonstick coatings make release easier, but they still benefit from a light coat of cooking spray or grease, especially in the center ring. Dishwasher-safe pans save time, though hand washing and drying keeps a coating in better shape for longer. Avoid metal utensils and abrasive scrubbers, and stay within the manufacturer's maximum oven temperature. Silicone is more forgiving of sticky batter, but it can stain and it needs support; neither material is indestructible.

Sets, Singles, and Storage

A two-pack of six-cavity pans is the most flexible buy for a household that bakes a dozen at a time: use one pan for a small batch or both for a full recipe. A single 12-cavity pan takes one slot in the cabinet and one tray in the oven, while a 20-cavity pan is for committed big-batch bakers. If storage is tight, stackable silicone molds or a single metal pan make more sense than a set you will rarely use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

We recommend the Wilton Gold two-pack for most bakers: two six-cavity pans, reliable release, and dishwasher-friendly cleanup make a full dozen feel routine.

If you want a heavier metal pan and do not mind hand washing, the Bellemain set is the step up; if you regularly bake for a crowd, the 20-cavity Wilton turns one recipe into a party batch. Silicone earns its place when easy release and flexible storage matter more than a browned crust.